Thursday, 29 October 2026

A dialogue with a voter

"You have to vote," they tell me.

People insist. 

"It's easy to enrol," they say (or said). 

But that's only relevant if I wanted to vote.

And I don't. I don't, because there is no one to vote for.

"But it's your duty. People fought for the right to vote."

The right to vote is also a a right not to vote. That's a vote for 'None of the Above.' And none of the above deserve my vote.

"But if you don’t choose, everyone else chooses for you."

But all the choices suck arse. So whomever everyone chooses will still suck arse.

"But you owe it to yourself and others to pay attention and make a choice!"

It's my attention to the candidates and their teams that tells me there's no choice amongst any of them worth getting out of bed for.

"But if you don't vote, the 'other team' will get in."

Things will happen that way even if I did vote. And what makes you think your team will be any better? 

"But this is the most important election in my lifetime!"

You don't think it's funny that every election is sold that same way?

"But if you don't like the government, then you have to vote against them."

You're voting against; but the team for whom you do vote for take your vote as an endorsement. As a mandate. Don't give it to them.

"But an hour of your time shapes three years of policy."

There is precisely zero chance that even three years of me voting would shape even a second of government policy. 

"But if you don't vote, you have no right to complain."

Contra that: if you do vote you're responsible for those speaking in your name. For all their theft and mendacity, all their threats and bullying, and all of their coercion and overspending. Your vote endorses all of that.

"But you can't complain about a government if you didn't vote."

Precisely wrong. It's only those who didn't vote for them who have any right to complain.

"So vote for the lesser of two evils."

The lesser of any number of evils is still evil. Why endorse that?

"But you speak for people who can’t vote. Children, the sick and the vulnerable are affected by the result but have no vote."

Then in that case they'd be better served by better candidates for office.

"But turnout is a mandate. A government elected by a bigger share of the people can claim to speak for them."

And a government elected on a low turnout might reflect that voters have refused to give them a mandate. 

"But silence reads as consent."

Precisely wrong. Silence too is a voice.

"But, but ... you have to vote."

No, you don't.

Don't vote. It only encourages them.

* * * * 

Q: Any other arguments for voting you've heard?

10 comments:

Terry said...

ACT is at least *trying* to play a tune that I like: more individual freedom, less government intervention.

Terry said...

And don't forget, Ayn Rand explicitly described her position as “Anti-Nixonites for Nixon” in the run-up to the 1972 U.S. presidential election, with her motive being to prevent McGovern from being elected. To apply what she wrote to our predicament: ACT can't be trusted to uphold individual rights. The hard Left can, however, be trusted to violate individual rights. I therefore see that it is in my interests to vote to lock out the hard Left.

Libertyscott said...

It's in my interests to delay or defer a growing state as much as possible. Sure ACT is flawed, a lot. However, up against a dominant culture of state parasitism, collectivist scapegoating and divisive domineering by very mediocre people who are at best naive, at worst psychopaths, I'll do a tiny bit to keep out the worst ones.

JP said...

1) The parties are obviously not equally evil.
2) Not voting is mathematically equivalent to voting for the average result.

Functionally, this makes you equivalent to a soft Labour / National supporter who might, or might not, get to the polls.

Peter Cresswell said...

@Terry, you said "ACT is at least *trying* to play a tune that I like."

A shame then that they're so badly out of tune.

NB: The hard Left can, always, be trusted to violate individual rights. What makes this election so unique? Where's the McGovern?

@Liberty Scott: ACT just played a part in enlarging govt debt and helping rewrite RMA 2.0 They have delayed nothing and, by their participation, have helped enlarge the growing. All while their leader has helped explain why property rights should ignored in Epsom and Tamaki electorates.

@JP:
1) Unequally evil is still evil.
2) Your maths needs work.

MarkT said...

With changes underway, what I do (land development) will almost certainly be better, or at least less worse under the current government compared to a left coalition. Right now we’re frantically working on a fast track application to meet the demand for much needed housing in a high growth area, which must be in before the election, because there’s a risk/likelihood Labour would pull the pin on any applications not already lodged, due to the tide of nimbyism the numerous fast track proposals have unleashed.

So unless you think I don’t know what I’m talking about in this space, you should be voting Act - who get some things right, and less objectionable than their other coalition partners. It’s not primarily about their abstract intentions, nor how many things you can point to them doing wrong, but the real differences it will make to our lives.

JP said...

@NotPC
"Unequally evil is still evil."
This is implicit in my first point. The point you concede by accepting "unequally" is the existence of party of minimum evil.

"Your maths needs work."
An unsupported opinion. My claim is that by not voting you don't change the average. This should be obvious. Which is functionally equivalent to casting a vote at the "average" value, since this also doesn't change the average.

The exercise of whether the average vote in NZ happens to coincide with the party of minimum evil is left to the reader.

Peter Cresswell said...

@MarkT: Great to hear that Bishop's fast-track can work in some places.
In Auckland however, ACT's leader and (then) deputy have been actively campaigning for several years AGAINST more housing. Fuck 'em.

MarkT said...

PC - If their policies were harming you, despite them helping me, that would be an entirely rational reaction. Biut I doubt that’s it. I suspect it’s an emotional reaction on your part (something like.”these fuckers aren’t doing what I’d do in their shoes, despite the fact they should know better”), in defiance of any rational calculation on your part.

Peter Cresswell said...

@Mark T: No, David Seymour and Brooke were explicit: they were against Auckland intensification.
The instant council were ready to allow people to build more on their land, Seymour and Van Velden became Ministers for Epsom + Tamaki rather than having any concern with property rights. Seymour explicitly said he was against people building townhouses that would look into constituents' pools.|
So they can get fucked.
If you do like fast track, which is one good thing that has happened from this govt, then you need to move to Hutt South to vote Chris Bishop, who's workit was -- because even his leader had to be dragged kicking and screaming to allow it.