Showing posts with label Politics-Greens. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Politics-Greens. Show all posts

Friday, 13 November 2026

Losers

With provisional election results in, Liberty Scott is ready to give his detailed verdict on the elections's under-achievers, non-achievers, and dead-set thorough-going losers. A few short slices here. Let's start with National:

Luxon didn’t inspire. He couldn’t even inspire the Labour Party to change its leader. A campaign that was part vapid slogans about “finishing the job”, with little sense of direction beyond empty marketing slogans, and part a scare campaign about new taxes and the Greens. ... There was little positivity, little creativity and little reflection of what had been [and still needed to be] done – to make government more efficient, to redirect money from bureaucracy to services, to build infrastructure, to make it easier to build houses and businesses, to end controversial policies like Three Waters, to cap rates, to refocus education on standards. Gutless, careless, witless and hopeless.
Seems accurate.

What about the Red Team?
It really didn’t look like Hipkins wanted to win. ... Labour’s campaign was cynical and angry, it promised little (as it couldn’t promise much without promising tax increases or spending cuts to save, and it wouldn’t do either). A campaign from a party not really wanting government, probably because it knows it could no better lift the economy and deliver meaningful improvements for people than National. No inspiration, no self-belief, no ambition, no point.
And the Green Team, who did enjoy a Minor success mainly because of TPM's overhang strategy
If we assume conservatively that half of the TPM electorate voters went to the Greens (the others to Labour), then without that the Greens would only have received 11.8% of the vote, that’s barely a whiff above 11.6% in 2023. ... [I]t is hardly a huge endorsement. I suspect moderate Greens might have drifted to Opportunity. ... Sure, they will celebrate a bigger caucus, which is needed because the past term saw two MPs resign under clouds of illegal behaviour.
Expect more of the same from that bigger caucus over the next three years. 

And what about the other and more minor parties? I  invite you to head over to Scott's blog for the rest ...

Friday, 23 October 2026

The economics of Magical Money Trees (MMT)

Underlying many of the wildest spending promises made by the most irresponsible political parties this election is an idea popularised by so-called Modern Monetary Theory, aka Magical Monetary Theory. This is the idea (as articulated by Chloe Swarbrick yesterday) that "the right-wing mythology around a government budget being the same as a household budget is exactly that, a mythology."  

According to MMT theory, government budgets differ different to normal household budgets (to over-simplify just a little bit) in that the money for government spending literally grows on trees.

If you need more, just print more.

To be perfectly fair, there's a little more to it than that. But not much. And for politicians promising billions of dollars of overspending, for whom the seduction of easy money is irresistible, anything close enough is good enough.

So what more is there? For a government like New Zealand that uses its own currency, MMT argues that government spending does not depend on first raising revenue through taxation or borrowing. Why? Because:
A monetary sovereign creates the dollars by spending and then those dollars disappear when taxed or are transformed into government bonds when the government runs a deficit. The government, therefore, is not financially constrained. MMT proponents argue that government deficits are private-sector surpluses, public debt is private wealth, and big government programs shouldn’t be limited by questions such as “How will we pay for it?” The real constraint, they insist, is the availability of labour and other resources.
So keep printing until all labour and resources are on fire. And then stop. 

"Stopping" is just one of the many political problems with the economic argument: there's barely a politician in the known universe who can stop (over)spending once started.

So it's fortunate that Jonathan Newman has enlisted several luminaries to explain in a new book, from an Austrian perspective, what the MMTers get wrong. [FREE DOWNLOAD HERE of an advance PDF copy].

Newman is also giving a chapter-by-chapter summary on Twitter of the main points, often engaging there with the theorists of MMT -- insofar as they're able to. These are some of the highlights...
Chapter 1 dismantles MMT’s foundational myth that money originated with the state. ...

Chapter 2 diagnoses the “spending illusion” that infects MMT. Joseph T. Salerno shows that MMT is “the unwanted stepchild of the neoclassical quantity theory” ... The spending illusion not only persists in MMT but is put on steroids, resulting in bizarre claims about how the state institutes money and policy prescriptions that “will inevitably distort prices and interest rates, divert resources from those uses that best serve consumer preferences, precipitate inflationary booms and asset bubbles, and generate financial crises and economic depressions.”

In chapter 3, Robert P. Murphy refutes the claim of MMT proponents that government debt represents private sector wealth. The so-called sectoral balance approach ["their debt is your money" say MMTers] is employed by MMT proponents in misleading ways. They imply that the only way the private sector as a whole can save and invest is if the government accumulates debt. Murphy exposes their faulty assumptions and sins of omission. Importantly, government debt is repaid with both explicit and implicit taxation (money creation), meaning that government debt service ultimately comes at the expense of the private sector. ... 

In chapter 4, Patrick Newman demolishes the idea that government spending can ever be productive. ... Government spending ...  should be considered consumption and not investment. Newman reviews the concerns held by Simon Kuznets [the inventor of GDP analysis] about the inclusion of government spending in aggregate production statistics, and then evaluates the growth-inhibiting consequences of government spending in light of its true nature: waste.

In chapter 5, Karl-Friedrich Israel exposes the faulty premises of MMT’s inflation management aspirations. MMT acknowledges that price inflation is an important constraint on government spending. [The author shows that] attempts to measure and respond to price inflation are bound to fail however ... [Furthermore] MMT has no dependable guide for determining if, when, and where government spending is pushing beyond productive capacity [or whether politicians would ever have the capacity to stop spending once started].
In chapter 6, Per L. Bylund points out [that] ... MMT proponents entirely ignore the wealth-creating, resource-economising market process—entrepreneurship and economic calculation are wholly absent from MMT analysis. Instead, they reason from accounting tautologies ... and assume that policymakers can effectively and efficiently manage scarce resources without market prices and the profit-and-loss mechanism.

In chapter 7, Joshua A. Mawhorter shows that MMT prescribes policy from a “privileged position,” taking for granted the laissez-faire preconditions for monetary sovereignty, and instead proposing policies that would undermine it. [Ayn Rand called reasoning like this as committing the Fallacy of the Stolen Concept.] It is this monetary sovereignty, according to MMT, that opens the door for deficit spending, debt monetisation, and government control of resources ... [yet a]chieving monetary sovereignty requires quite the opposite: limited government, sound money, and a flourishing private market economy based on capital accumulation. The US is the MMT proponents’ “monetary sovereign par excellence,” but its economic history exhibits institutions and policies condemned by MMT.

Chapter 8 is the chopping block for the MMT job guarantee proposal [reflected in the Greens's own $8 billion "green jobs guarantee"]... MMT overlooks the fact that apparently idle resources are in such a state for a reason. Resources may have no known valuable use or may be held idle temporarily because the owner anticipates a valuable use in the future. Labourers may withhold their services because they value leisure more highly or as a negotiating tactic in a labour strike. A ... job guarantee programme [financed by printed money] would not reduce idleness in the way MMT proponents desire but merely redirect valuable resources and labour away from productive and economising uses and toward wasteful projects chosen by central planners who are inherently unable to engage in economic calculation.

As you'd expect, the book is filled with countless examples illustrating the arguments. 

It's out officially in December, but fortunately you can download a PDF advance copy now just in time to send a copy to your favourite politician ...




Monday, 19 October 2026

French youth are rioting about the wrong thing

Parisians are right to protest. But they're throwing rocks at the wrong thing.

In Paris they're rioting again about the price of bread -- 
against hardship in schools and the rising cost of living. Their target this time: the capitalists who (they say) are making the cost of living unbearable.

And yet, as French entrepreneur Brivael Le Pogam reminds us in this Guest Post, "capitalism is the force that drove down the price of almost everything it touched." And at the same time the state is the force "that blew up the price of almost everything it captured." So why are young people are out in the streets blaming the first for the crimes of the second -- vilifying billionaire producers while demanding more of the same from the state?

French writer 
Brivael Le Pogam (author of The Shifting Wall) points out the strange the disconnection, here and elsewhere, of young activists from the causes they protest...

French youth are rioting about the wrong thing
by Brivael Le Pogam

On my way to the office this morning, I passed a group of young people protesting, a Palestinian flag draped over their shoulders. 

And I asked myself a question I can't shake: why does this generation always fall into the same trap? No matter the history. No matter the context. Even the ones from wealthy families, who went to the best schools, who were dealt every good card. Always the same trap. 

I don't think it's stupidity. I think it's a mechanism. And a mechanism can be taken apart, piece by piece. 

A. The observation: everything the state touches becomes unaffordable. 

Look at economist Mark Perry's famous chart below, the one people call "the chart of the century." It tracks US prices since 2000. 

At the top, what explodes: hospital services, college tuition, textbooks, childcare, housing. Increases of +100%, +150%, up to +250%, far above general inflation. 

At the bottom, what collapses: TVs, software, phones, toys, clothing. A TV today costs a fraction of what it did in 2000, for an infinitely better product. 
And then look at what separates the two groups. It isn't technology. It isn't complexity. It's one variable, and one variable alone: how much the state is involved. 

At the top: sectors that are subsidised, regulated, shielded from competition; where the state funds demand and blocks supply. At the bottom: sectors where companies fight every single morning to serve you better and cheaper. 

B. The mechanism: why it's systematic. 

When the state subsidises demand without freeing supply, prices rise. Every time. Guaranteed student loans, and universities raise tuition. Housing aid [incl. accommodation supplements] plus blocked building consents, and rents and prices skyrocket. Administered healthcare, and bureaucracy eats the budget before it ever reaches the patient. 

In France it's even more vicious, because the price doesn't disappear: it hides. You never see the hospital bill, you pay it through payroll contributions. [In New Zealand you simply pay it through your taxes.] You never see the cost of school, you pay it through taxes. [In New Zealand you simply pay it through even more taxes.] Public spending at 57% of GDP, one of the heaviest tax burdens in the world, more than €3.4 trillion in debt. And the result? Overflowing Emergency Rooms, falling PISA scores, young people who can't afford to live in the city where they work. 

The market didn't fail in these sectors. It was never allowed in. 

C. Suffering demands a culprit. 

A 22-year-old lives all of this in their bones. They can't find a place to live. Their degree either buries them in debt or opens no doors. The future feels blocked. That suffering is real, and one can't deny it for a second. 

But human beings can't stand suffering without a culprit. They need a face. A scapegoat. 

And this is where everything is decided: who taught them how to read the world? 

D. Whoever tells the story picks the villain. 

Schools are public. Universities are public. Culture runs on grants. Film goes through funding committees. Public broadcasting shapes the narratives. The people handing down the interpretive framework are, overwhelmingly, paid by the very system that creates the problem. 

Do you really think that system is going to name itself as the culprit? No. It names the capitalist. The boss. The landlord. "The rich." The billionaire. The multinational. The commercial West. Same role, same casting, every time. 

E. One lens, a thousand causes. 

And this brings me back to that flag. A generation taught to read every situation through a single lens, oppressor on one side, rich, Western, capitalist, oppressed on the other, will apply that lens everywhere. To housing. To climate. To conflicts on the other side of the world. The cause changes, the lens stays. That's why the trap is always the same: it's not the cause that draws them in, it's the way of thinking that was installed in them. 

F. The perfect inversion. 

Here's the irony. Capitalism is the force that drove down the price of almost everything it touched. The state is the force that blew up the price of almost everything it captured. And yet young people blame the first for the crimes of the second. 

It's like blaming the firefighter for the fire because you saw him at the scene. 

G. The ballot box confirms it. In the US, a few weeks out from the midterms, a large share of urban young voters is getting ready to vote Democrat for more state, more spending, more regulation. New York elected a self-described socialist mayor, carried by young voters, on promises of rent freezes and city-run grocery stores. Rent freezes, the policy that has made housing scarcer everywhere it's been tried. The cure that worsens the disease.

Here in New Zealand, a large share are preparing to vote Greens; to demonise billionaires, soak the rich, and demand more regulation and rent control; and to load a $230 billion tax bill onto New Zealand taxpayers over the next parliamentary term.

In France, it's the same play in two acts. Part of the youth votes for the radical left, which promises more state. Another part votes for the centre, which promises to "manage" the state well, and has dug the debt deeper than ever. Two different ballots, one shared assumption: that the problem is the market, and the solution is the state. 

H. The way out. 

These young people aren't stupid. They're right to be angry. They're just aiming at the wrong target. 

The day they understand that their rent, their tuition and their hospital are expensive precisely because the state runs them, their anger will change direction. They'll stop protesting against those who create. They'll start protesting against those who capture. 

That day, the greatest intellectual scam of our time will be over.

* * * * 
Brivael Le Pogam is a French tech entrepreneur, founder of founder of French AI company Argil and the author of 'The Shifting Wall: Why the West Thought It Had Won in 1989 and How to Get Back to Work. He tweets here. This guest post has been lightly edited for a New Zealand audience.

"...and some of that agenda actually makes the poor worse off."

 

"Those who are primarily concerned about the well-being of the poor are likely to discover over time that much of the agenda of the left does not really do much good for the poor, and some of that agenda -- environmental extremism, for example -- actually makes the poor worse off."

~ Thomas Sowell, from his 2000 column 'Poverty and the Left'

"Capitalism has created the highest standard of living ever known on earth. The evidence is incontrovertible. The contrast between West and East Berlin [or South and North Korea] is the latest demonstration, like a laboratory experiment for all to see. Yet those who are loudest in proclaiming their desire to eliminate poverty are loudest in denouncing capitalism. Man's well-being is not their goal."
~ Ayn Rand from her essay 'Theory and Practice,' collected in her anthology Capitalism: The Unknown Ideal

Thursday, 1 October 2026

The Greens's multi-billion dollar fiscal hole

I did know that the Greens are economically illiterate. I hadn't realised just how innumerate until I saw the so-called Taxpayers' Union's Bribe-O-Meter -- prepared for the election so you can see how much each party promises to bribe you with your own money.

As irresponsible as the ACT Party is, their bribes only amount to three-quarters of a billion. More than they should be, but less than they might be.

As profligate as Team National is, they're still just promising bribes amounting to two billion dollars.

And then there's a big jump. Barbara Edmonds is still barely to quote a number of her own this year, but the Taxpayers Union reckon her Labour Party will be bribing you with over fifty billion -- about the same as Winston First.

If you think that was a big jump, then settle back: Chloe Swarbrick's Greens -- the party who reckon she should be the Finance Minister in the next government -- are bribing you with a total of $236.72 billion over the next parliamentary term. Almost a quarter of a trillion dollars! That equates to $114, 245 per household!

You can read the detailed breakdown here. Here's a summary:
  • Social spending is costed at $178.7 billion over four years, or $86,234 per household, by far the largest single category. 
  • Extending ACC to cover all injuries, disability and illness regardless of origin accounts for $96 billion of that alone
  • Lifting benefits to "liveable rates" adds a further $27.6 billion
  • On education, a universal student allowance to cover basic needs is costed at $14.4 billion, and free tertiary education up to a first degree at $8 billion
  • The party's proposed student loan write-off carries a $16.2 billion balance sheet impact
  • Free early childhood education for all is costed at $5.4 billion
  • Free school lunches for all kids in all schools at $2.2 billion
  • Expanding free apprenticeship programmes at $200 million
That's an awful lot of "free" stuff to be paid by someone else: That's you, the voter.

But we haven't even finished the promised bribes.  Their next biggest bribe is on something they call "economic development" ....

  • Economic development spending is costed at $40.8 billion over four years
  • The largest confirmed commitment is a nationwide rapid rail network, costed at $17.2 billion
  • Comprehensive bus lanes in all cities are costed at $1.2 billion
  • EV subsidies at $337 million, based on reintroducing the Clean Car Discount scheme.
  • A further $9.4 billion is costed for tens of thousands of new public homes, based on forecast 2026/27 house-building spend and the maximum build rate achieved in 2023/24, 
  • This is alongside $21 million for a Certified Rental Warrant of Fitness.
  • Regional support commitments add $2.4 billion for the Te Rangatiratanga Trust, $2 billion for a new intergenerational fund, and $400 million for a Te Rākau restoration fund.
  • Energy policies add a further $3.05 billion, made up of Kiwipower ($980.6 million), expanding Warmer Homes ($969.8 million), solar on all public housing stock ($460 million), zero-interest solar loans ($428.7 million), community-owned energy ($200 million), and increased EECA funding ($12.4 million).
  • The Greens' plans to purchase 120 supermarkets to form a state-run supermarket chain is costed at $4.7 billion, or $2,259 per household. 
  • Creating a tribunal for dealing with disputes arising from auctioning off commercial leases on unoccupied lots has been costed at $7.2 million.
I don't know about you, but I don't see a lot of economic development coming therefrom.

Next biggest item is on developing bigger government. This doesn't come cheap.
  • The Greens' policy to lift core public service pay by 10 percent is costed at $15.5 billion over four years
Over fifteen billion to employ more bureaucrats.

And finally, on to their bribes in Environment and Arts -- only a comparatively minor item, considering they were once an environmental party ...
  • Environment and conservation commitments total $1.5 billion over four years
  • This includes $1.2 billion to expand Jobs for Nature, $200 million to introduce a price on agricultural emissions, $90 million to restore the Ministry for the Environment, and $13.5 million to increase funding for the EPA and community environment groups.
  • $200 million has also been promised for the promotion of te reo Māori.

=> And that's how we get the figure, for all of the promised bribes, of $236.72 billion over the next parliamentary term (equating to $114, 245 per household).

And just how does this all get paid for?

I'm glad you asked, because it hasn't apparently occurred to the innumerate Auckland Central MP to reconcile bribes with revenue. As of today's date ...
The Greens' tax plan, released in June, promises more than $32 billion of new revenue over four years. It relies on a "super-rich tax" (their renamed wealth tax) and an inheritance and gifts tax. (The current Wealth Tax has already been revised down by fifty percent since last year's "alternative budget." Expect any return, if implemented to continue that trend.)
They would also lifts the corporate tax rate for some firms and reverses the coalition's changes to interest deductibility.
Consistent with their something for nothing promises, that's all the revenue they promise to extract from you. So how would the rest of those bribes be paid? Answer: borrowing.
  • The Taxpayers' Union describes a $60 billion infrastructure borrowing programme as part of the Greens' pledges, with interest of about $12 billion.
But even with that aspirational fantasy of a $32 billion Wealth Tax and saddling the few remaining taxpayers with $60 billion of borrowing (and another $12 billion interest bill), that still leaves a massive hole. 

A hole of nearly one-hundred and fifty billion  dollars!

How would that be paid? Somehow. That's how.
UPDATE: Of course Greens supporters will object that there is. no fiscal hole, that governments can spend as much as they like -- that money does grow on trees just as long as it's government that grows them. 

In its latest guise, called MMT by its supporters (aka Magical Monetary Theory) -- the  populist idea (already promoted by the UK Greens) that governments can spend spend spend and do not need to raise tax to finance it. Professor John Hearn explains that it's not just wrong, but dangerously wrong...

Tuesday, 25 August 2026

"The Green Party’s supermarket policy is a textbook example of how modern ideological movements drift toward retroactive punishment."

Chloe Swarbrick: 'Yes, I alone will decide how much profit you will make. Or not.'
"One of the most valuable inheritances from Roman law is the prohibition on retroactive legislation; the principle that what is lawful today cannot be declared unlawful tomorrow and punished after the fact. Civilisation depends on this. Without it, citizens cannot plan, cannot trust the law, and cannot defend themselves against the State. The rule of law collapses into rule by law — law as a weapon. ...

"The Green Party’s supermarket policy is a textbook example of how modern ideological movements drift toward retroactive punishment. Their proposal to penalise 'excessive profit' or 'price gouging' sounds simple until you ask the only question that matters: excessive according to what standard?

"So far, no standard exists.

"Chlöe Swarbrick has been unable to articulate:
 
  • how “excessive profit” would be defined, 
  • what baseline would be used, 
  • whether the metric would be tied to past behaviour, 
  • or how businesses could know in advance whether they were compliant.
"Without a clear, objective, forward‑looking definition, the policy becomes retroactive by default. It allows the State to declare, after the fact, that last year’s lawful profit was actually this year’s unlawful 'gouging.' That is not regulation; it is ex post facto punishment disguised as economic justice.

"This is precisely the danger Roman jurists warned about. Law must be knowable before action, not invented after action."

Monday, 27 July 2026

Chlöe cries crocodile tears

NEWS: 'Greens push for pause to big data centres consents, citing rising power prices.'

"Net Zero and the deployment of wind and solar generation put far more upward pressure on power prices than AI data centres do. The NZ public have never had a say on whether NZ should pursue Net Zero or not. How about we have a referendum on this?"
~ Zaphodd BB
"You'd think the Greens would want more data centres in NZ serving the world, given our electricity is 95% renewable and therefore better for the planet. Guess popularist derr brainery is more important than lowering carbon emissions eh..."
~ Lewis Holden
"The instinct is 'capitalists are doing something we don’t understand and didn’t think of, so it should stop until we think we understand it and can tie it up in rules so it looks like something we can tolerate grudgingly'.”
~ Liberty Scott
"Green Party co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick says massive power-hungry AI data centres risk driving up electricity prices for the impoverished. Yet, as she knows, her push for Net Zero makes rising electricity prices a 100% certainty. She cries crocodile tears."

~ Peter Cresswell 

Monday, 20 April 2026

Simple Swarbrick

"Mainstream Media reports that the Green Party will campaign on mass electrification for the election, saying the sun, wind, water and geothermal energy 'don’t come through the Strait of Hormuz.'

"Chloe Swarbrick with that wild-eyed enthusiasm that only she is capable of offers a simplistic solution. I use the word 'simplistic' advisedly. She herself says the solution is simple. ... Swarbrick said the Government needed to create a national electrification plan ...starting with improving access to 'cheap, easy loans for solar panels and batteries' ... 'tak[ing] control of our country’s own needs by powering ourselves, with every renewable resource available in abundance around us.' Would that it were so easy. ...

"[T]hink about a few things.;
  • Is what Swarbrick proposes really a solution?
  • Does she really know what she is talking about?
  • Is she aware of the pervasiveness of the petrochemical industry in our day to day lives and how much we depend upon it?
  • Have she and the Greens really thought through this policy or is it an easy one to articulate.
  • Or in fact are Swarbrick and the Greens speaking and policy making from a position of unawareness or ignorance of the nature of the problem?
"And if the answer to the preceding question is in the affirmative, do they have any business being near the levers of power. ...

"Think about it and ... about the pervasiveness of the petrochemical industry and how much we depend upon it."

Thursday, 9 April 2026

"The Greens are proposing one of the most aggressive tax regimes of its kind anywhere in the developed world..."

 

"The Greens are proposing one of the most aggressive tax regimes of its kind anywhere in the developed world, resulting in a broad-based raid on Kiwis who’ve worked hard, saved, and built something over a lifetime. 
"The idea this only hits the wealthy simply doesn't stack up. One in five Kiwi homes is held in a trust, and the Greens would tax those assets from the first dollar. In Auckland, that means an annual bill of over $18,000 on a mortgage-free family home, or $3,600 for first home buyers with a twenty-percent deposit.

"And it doesn't stop there. A 33 percent death tax would force many families to sell farms, homes, or businesses just to pay the bill. Inheriting the average dairy farm would trigger a $1.2 million tax bill. There is nothing fair about taxing grief, or taxing the same income again when it's earned, saved, and finally passed on.

"Most countries that have tried wealth taxes have scrapped them because they drive investment and talent offshore. Death taxes are even worse, New Zealand tried one and abandoned it in 1993 because it crushed farming families and raised almost nothing.

“This package is light on evidence, heavy on populism, and green with envy.”

~ Austin Ellingham-Banks on the Taxpayer Union's 'NEW REPORT: Green With Envy: Wealth, Death, And Trust Taxes Examined'
"One 'solution' to inequality ... is the wealth tax. ... This taxing away of capital means less means of production and thus less production and higher prices. At the same time, it means less demand for labour and thus lower wages. [The] programme is a call for mass impoverishment....
"Taxing wealth is not merely a levy on individuals but a direct seizure of the capital required for production, which ultimately harms everyone's standard of living. ...
"As [Ludwig Von] Mises observed* ...., almost all of the technological advances of the last centuries are available to and can be fully understood by engineers in even the most impoverished corners of the world. What stops the implementation of those advances is not any lack of technological knowledge but a lack of capital. Thus, a farmer in India who has seen a tractor on television can easily understand the value of using one. What stops him from using one is certainly not any lack of technological knowledge. It is certainly not that he does not know how to operate a tractor or could not easily be taught how to do so. What stops him is that he cannot afford a tractor. He does not possess the capital necessary to buy a tractor and cannot find a lender to provide it. This is a lack of capital that probably could not be made good by any rise in the local capital/income ratio. It reflects generations of insufficient local capital accumulation."
~ George Reisman from his comment on 'The Problem with the Wealth Tax' and his 'Piketty’s Capital: Wrong Theory/Destructive Program' [emphases mine]

"New Zealand’s productivity challenges are strongly linked to low capital intensity. ... New Zealand’s slowing labour productivity growth is likely to reflect both slowing growth in innovation and declines in the capital to labour ratio. ... New Zealand’s capital intensity [already] lags other countries...."
~ Treasury from their 2024 report 'Causes of New Zealand’s low capital intensity'

* Ludwig Von Mises, in his chapter 'Capital Supply & American Prosperity'--in which he observes that "the average standard of living is in [America] is higher than in any other country of the world, not because the American statesmen and politicians are superior to the foreign statesmen and politicians, but because the per-head quota of capital invested is in America higher than in other countries."

Tuesday, 31 March 2026

Rent Control Always Fails—Argentina Shows a Better Way


Chloe Swarbrick's Green Party are promising a 2 percent annual cap on rent increases. At first glance that might sound compassionate, but as Matthew Horncastle observes, "In reality it is a textbook example of bad economics."

As virtually every economist has told us for decades, “In many cases, rent control appears to be the most efficient technique presently known to destroy a city except for bombing.” Politicians keep promising the same thing not so they can actually fix the problem -- even the most inept political reptile is aware of this -- but to win votes from people who still think that emotions can trump the reality of a rent cap.

As Marcos Falcone points out in this guest post, it's not even necessary to understand the reasons for rent control being do destructive. In contrasting the experience of Spain and Argentina, where xxx, he shows what the Greens and Green voters should realise before helping to destroy rental accommodation here...

Rent Control Always Fails—Argentina Shows a Better Way

by Marcos Falcone

On Friday, March 20, in light of the Iran war, which has pushed up energy and other prices, Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez announced measures to lower the cost of living. Rent control was included among those measures, even though it is already failing in Spain.

Reportedly under pressure from one of its left-wing coalition partners, Sánchez decreed a nationwide contract extension at current prices for rentals about to expire, effectively amounting to a rent freeze. He has also instituted a 2 percent annual cap on rent increases through the end of 2027, which will apply to existing contracts currently indexed to inflation.

Ironically, a report published by the Instituto Juan de Mariana the same week as Sánchez’s announcement shows the extent of the harm that various forms of rent control are already causing in Spain. Following the introduction of rent caps in the region of Catalonia in 2024, the supply of rental housing has declined by 23 percent. Even more dramatically, the city of A Coruña and the region of Navarra saw rental supply fall by 44 percent and 51 percent, respectively, only six months after they designated certain areas as “stressed” housing markets and also imposed rent caps. 

In a country with an estimated deficit of 700,000 housing units, rent control is making things even worse.

Rent control in Spain not only cuts supply but also fails to improve conditions for renters. As the Instituto Juan de Mariana shows, wherever rent control has recently been introduced, average rental unit space has decreased, and prices per square meter have either stayed the same or increased—in Barcelona, for example, prices reached a record high in the third quarter of 2025.

The Spanish experience contrasts sharply with Argentina’s, which has adopted the exact opposite approach since Javier Milei became president in December 2023. 

Before then, listings had plunged by a massive 53 percent following the passage of a rent control law in 2020. But after Milei repealed it ten days after taking office, supplies rose by a staggering 180 percent less than a year and a half later. (My colleague Ryan Bourne and I documented that extensively here). 

As of December 2025, rental prices in the city of Buenos Aires were still almost 30 percent down in real terms from two years before, and supply has not declined.

Rent control does more harm than good, as Ryan Bourne explains in The War on Prices. Hopefully, Spain will correct course as Argentina did before things get much worse.

* * * * 
Marcos Falcone is a policy analyst focusing on Latin America at the Cato Institute’s Center for Global Liberty and Prosperity. His research interests range from contemporary public policy in his home country of Argentina to the history, theory, and language of classical liberalism. His essays have received awards by the Mont Pelerin Society, Caminos de la Libertad, and the European Center for Austrian Economics, among others. His columns appear frequently in Argentine and US media.

His post first appeared at the Cato at Liberty blog.

Monday, 9 February 2026

Catastrophic sewage failure starts with pisspoor decision-making

"[T]he cause of the calamity are ... sitting, neatly itemised, in Wellington City Council’s own records. ...

"On 27 May 2021, Wellington City Council’s Long-Term Plan Committee faced a clear fork in the road."Officers presented councillors with water investment options, including one — Water Option 3 — that contained a $391 million wastewater renewals programme... to reduce sewage pollution, starting with the central city and south-coast catchments now making headlines.

"At the same meeting, officers recommended Cycleways Option 3, with capital expenditure of $120 million over ten years. ... An amendment was moved by then-councillor [and now Green MP] Tamatha Paul ... to adopt Cycleways Option 4, expanding the programme to $226 million — nearly doubling it.

"That amendment passed.

"Accelerated wastewater renewal did not.

"The vote is on video. The numbers are in the Long-Term Plan. The consequences are now floating in Cook Strait."

~ Peter Bassett from his post 'Wellington’s Sewage Crisis Wasn’t an Accident. It Was a Vote — and Everyone’s Pretending Not to Remember'

Thursday, 29 January 2026

The Return of Chloe's Wealth Tax

Watch any rant by Chloe Swarbrick and, after the obligatory nods to te reo, to Palestine, and to passing laws to change the weather, she'll tell you that it's time for "the wealthy" to fund everything every government could dream of. 

It's really the only substantive policy she can articulate. Yet she remains blithely unaware that the fortunes she want to sack are not gold bars under the mattress but ownership stakes in operating companies, real estate, and other productive assets, so her Wealth Tax would function as a direct penalty on those investments. That penalty doesn’t remain confined to the wealthy. Capital formation is what drives productivity growth and wage gains, and policies that discourage it ultimately leave everyone worse off.

As Adam Michel explains in this Guest Post, the chronic government spending growth she advocates cannot be paid for by ever more aggressive taxes on a narrow subset of high-income taxpayers.  Not even in a US more stocked with billionaires than she'll ever see here ...

The Return of the Wealth Tax, Evidence Against Them Is Stronger Than Ever

by Adam Michel

Wealth taxes are back in the policy conversation— a good opportunity to review how wealth taxes work and why they have been called “one of the most harmful taxes ever created.”

Wealth taxes are unique in that they are not levied on an annual flow of income or consumption (like a sales tax). Instead, wealth taxes apply to a stock of assets and are usually intended to be primarily redistributive, aiming to reverse a perceived inequality in the distribution of resources.

Wealth taxes promise redistribution but more often deliver high economic costs, administrative complexity, and disappointing revenue. California’s proposal  to impose a broad-based wealth tax on the state’s billionaires illustrates how these taxes distort investment decisions, magnify fiscal volatility, and tend to evolve from one-time levies into permanent features of strained budgets.

Wealth Taxes In the Real World

Wealth taxes impose an additional layer of tax on the income generated by the underlying asset. Most wealth consists of productive assets deployed in the economy, such as active businesses and other physical investments. The annual income streams generated by the underlying assets—capital gains, dividends, and interest—are taxed through the normal income tax system.

The existing tax system already charges the wealthiest Americans high tax rates. A Biden administration Treasury study found that the wealthiest 92 Americans faced total state, local, federal, and international income tax rates of 59 percent. Recent research by four prominent liberal economists concludes that US billionaires pay higher tax rates than their counterparts in the Netherlands, Sweden, Norway, and France, and, contrary to the headline claim, the wealthiest taxpayers also pay the highest tax rates among all Americans.

Because wealth taxes are assessed on a stock instead of an annual income flow, expressing the tax rate as an equivalent income tax rate is more informative. Unless the taxpayer is expected to slowly sell off their underlying assets, the tax will be paid from annual income. Table 1 shows the equivalent income tax rate on underlying assets with different rates of return at different wealth tax rates. At the California top wealth tax rate of 5 percent, any asset earning less than a 5 percent annual pre-tax return would face income tax rates above 100 percent before paying other taxes. Bernie Sanders’ 2020 campaign proposal included a top wealth tax rate of 8 percent.

Net wealth taxes have been tested in other countries and repealed due to high economic costs and administrative burdens. Peaking at 12 in the 1990s, only four Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) countries still impose broad-based net wealth taxes today: Colombia, Norway, Spain, and Switzerland. The figure below shows the trend of wealth taxes over time.

Economic and Administrative Costs

Wealth taxes can impose confiscatory effective tax rates with predictable economic consequences. By directly reducing the after-tax return to saving and investment, they weaken incentives to build businesses, expand productive capacity, and take entrepreneurial risks. Because most large fortunes are not gold bars under the mattress but ownership stakes in operating companies, real estate, and other productive assets, a wealth tax functions as a direct penalty on those investments. That penalty doesn’t remain confined to the wealthy. Capital formation is what drives productivity growth and wage gains, and policies that discourage it ultimately leave everyone worse off.

Wealth taxes also distort capital allocation. Investors have a strong incentive to shift portfolios toward assets that are harder to value, easier to shelter, or more mobile across borders, rather than toward their most productive use. This encourages tax avoidance rather than genuine economic activity. It can mean less investment in long-term projects, more leverage, and greater reliance on complex financial arrangements to reduce reported net worth.

Wealth taxes are also administratively complex. Valuing a broad range of assets every year is extraordinarily difficult. Unlike easy-to-value publicly traded stocks, most wealth is tied up in closely held businesses, partnerships, real estate, artwork, and other illiquid or unique assets. Annual valuation invites avoidance and disputes, which raises compliance costs for both governments and taxpayers. It took 12 years for the IRS and the Michael Jackson estate to reach a court-mediated agreement on the value of its taxable assets. Going through such a process every year for all taxpayers with assets above or near the tax threshold is administratively impracticable.

Because of persistent administrative difficulties and taxpayers’ behavioural responses, wealth taxes raise comparatively little revenue. Countries that experiment with wealth taxes repeatedly find that taxpayers adjust their behaviour or move in large numbers, undermining optimistic revenue forecasts. Before France repealed its net wealth tax in 2018, the government estimated that “some 10,000 people with 35 billion euros worth of assets left in the past 15 years.” 

Spain experienced a similar behavioural response following the 2023 “solidarity tax,” which raised just 40 percent of the projected revenue. Cato’s Chris Edwards summarises that “European wealth taxes typically raised only about 0.2 percent of GDP in revenues. Given the little revenue raised, it is not surprising that they had ‘little effect on wealth distribution,’ as one study noted.”

California’s Proposal Is a Warning for the Country

California’s proposed 5 percent wealth tax is especially notable because it would layer on top of the most progressive tax system in the OECD. The state already relies on taxpayers making over half a million dollars a year (the highest income 2.5 percent) to pay 49 percent of income tax revenue. They do this by combining high marginal income tax rates and heavy reliance on capital gains taxation, which makes revenues volatile and highly sensitive to the fortunes and domiciling decisions of a small number of taxpayers.

The initiative’s own findings make clear that this will not be a one-time tax. The ballot text explains that the wealth tax “would only modestly slow” the growth of billionaires’ fortunes in California. That admission undermines the premise that the tax solves any underlying fiscal or wealth distribution problem. If a tax leaves wealth largely intact, political pressure to repeat, expand, or permanently extend it is inevitable. This is what happened in Spain, when its “exceptional and temporary” wealth tax became permanent. California’s proposal should be understood in this light, not as a one-off correction, but as a test case for permanent wealth confiscation.

The lesson extends beyond California. Chronic spending growth cannot be solved by ever more aggressive taxes on a narrow subset of high-income taxpayers. Wealth taxes are not a solution to budgetary or economic gaps; they are a symptom of a broken fiscal system grasping for short-term revenue while postponing the difficult but necessary work of restraining spending growth. 

* * * * 

Adam Michel is director of tax policy studies at the Cato Institute, where he focuses on analysing the economic and budgetary effects of taxation in the United States.
    He is widely published and quoted in the Wall Street Journal, the New York Times, the Washington Post, and elsewhere. He has also appeared on Fox News, CNN, and CNBC to discuss tax policy and its economic effects. In addition to numerous book chapters, his scholarly work has been published in the Journal of Public Budgeting and Finance and Tax Notes.
    His post first appeared at the Cato at Liberty blog.

Friday, 6 June 2025

Yes, this is pathetic.

The reason for the punishment. Threats not immediately obvious.
Yes, it's accurate to call Te Pāti Māori a racist party — both its constituencies and policies are race-based. Like Wee Willy Jackson, who spoke yesterday against them being banned for 21 days, they view everything through a lens focussed on race.

"The world is watching'" said Jackson, "and this type of punitive punishment will enshrine and entrench in world political commentators, and certainly the Māori Party, that this place is indeed racist and that there's no hope for this place. That's how bad that decision is."* TPM MPs and other were happy to pile on and magnify his point. "Everyone can see the racism," said Takuta Ferris. " It is hardly being hidden." "Racism-whistling," said Marama Davidson. "Racism," said Ms Hapi-Clarke. Racism, racism, racism.

Baloney.

It's just a Parliament trying to maintain the illusion that its members deserve any sort of respect. 

As Chloe Swarbrick pointed out, it's a place full of of humbug: Winston stood up and preached about "contempt" — TPM's "utter contempt for the whole institution." Yet "the last time ... that the Privileges Committee did not make a consensus-based decision," cited Swarbrick in her speech, "in fact it was—and here I am reading explicitly from the Privileges Committee report back then—'for the Member, the Rt Hon Winston Peters, who knowingly provided false or misleading information on a pecuniary interest.'" MPs of course caring nothing for how much they lie to you, but who get upset (or pretend to) when they're seen to lie to each other.

But as for those wanting to punish these MPs by removing them from the House for an unprecedented period?

Don't be so bloody precious.

The Parliament needs some formality in order to function, to allow violently-opposed views to be heard and debated. But it also needs some theatre — and no-one could argue that Han-Rawhiti Maipi-Clarke's defiant rip-up-and-haka conclusion to the Treaty Principles Bill wasn't great theatre.

And let's not get all uptight about the alleged "threats" against the ACT Party front bench. If threats alone were enough to ban an MP for three weeks then Julie Anne Genter might be permanently on leave.

It was National Party MPs who escalated all this by arguing for a 21-day ban. And let's not forget it was ACT Party MP Parmjeet Parmar who investigated imprisonment as a possible punishment. Imprisonment!

Was that racism? No, it was simply irresponsible. (And in Parmar's case, authoritarian.)

Yesterday the Māori Party co-leader was still berating the "coloniser government" for punishing them. Maybe they should take a leaf out of Sin Fein's book, who also refused to concede the legitimacy of their Parliament. But in the Westminster Parliament Sinn Fein take their stand seriously: their seven MPs refuse to front at all.

* * * * 

* To be fair, Jackson was a bit more subtle than that. "These people on the other side," he said, "they're not all Ku Klux Klan members .... Some of them are quite good."

Tuesday, 20 May 2025

"The Greens' vision a pathway to Venezuela"

"LET'S STRIP AWAY THE political gloss and assess the Green Party’s 2025 budget for what it is: a document heavy on ideology, neo-Marxist buzzwords, and te reo, but dangerously light on pragmatism, economic credibility, and operational realism. ...

"Fundamentally, their budget is about lifting government revenue by taxing New Zealanders an extra $88billion over four years. They have no plan for growing the economy. ... for additional capital, the Greens have decided to simply borrow more. ...

"Included in the Greens tax grab are following revenue channels: Inheritance Tax [i.e., Death Tax]... Private Jet Tax ... 10-year Brightline test ... Labour’s removal of interest deductibility for residential property ... Companies/Corporate Tax [hike] ... Income Tax [threshold] change ... Mining Royalties [hike] ... Wealth Tax...

"It is worth remembering that the Green Party only claims these policies will generate nearly $90 billion in new revenue over four years. This is an implausibly optimistic figure. The reality is you can’t just plug in tax rates and expect static revenue. People adapt and restructure in reaction to law changes and shifting systems. Sometimes they just straight up leave. These are not 'guaranteed billions.' They are some pretty wild assumptions disguised as policy. ...

"CLAIMING TO HAVE FOUND $88 billion in additional revenue thanks to taxing the shizzzzz out of New Zealanders, the Greens have gone to town spending big. ... their budget is more manifesto than fiscal plan. At the heart of the document is the assumption that profit should be avoided and the state should act to hamper it as much as possible. Other assumptions of note relate to their allergic reaction to anything that remotely suggests that adults should be responsible for their own wellbeing. ...

"In classic modern Marxist fashion, they are determined to try things that have already failed multiple times over in other jurisdictions. ...The biggest problem with [their] extensive list of spending [outside the morality of altruism and theft, Ed.] ... is that there’s clearly a lack of capacity in our systems to deliver any of these services. ...

"It is also a strategy that assumes infinite government competence. The Greens are highly critical of our existing systems and yet they want to expand them, give them vastly more power, and put them under further pressure. ...

"'As Venezuelans have learned over the past 20 years of socialism, “free things” come at a high price'.' ...

"Most depressing of all, in my view is the way the Greens would set out to cause lifelong structural dependency on the state. Accusations of Marxism and socialism are often overblown, but in this case they are truly warranted. This plan contains no serious expectations of any personal responsibility nor any incentives to engage in commerce and grow the economy. Guaranteed incomes, regardless of effort, encourage longterm unemployment or permanent student life. There’s no point in saving, working hard, starting a business, or taking financial risks. In fact, those who do would be penalised severely by the Greens through taxation. This is a social model built not on empowerment, but entitlement. ...

"This budget is a blueprint for turning our country into the next Venezuela. It is easy to dismiss the insanity of the Greens as the fantasies of the irrelevant, but the assumption that will not get close to the levers of power is a naive one. ... unless MMP is overhauled ..."

~ Ani O'Brien from her posts 'The Greens' vision a pathway to Venezuela' and 'Greens' moral crusade masquerading as an economic plan
WATCH: Greens's co-leaderette Chloe Swarbrick attempts defending the impossible against Jack Tame's timid prodding:

Friday, 16 May 2025

"The Greens’ Budget is more than just a Budget. It is their utopian vision for a different country."

"[T]he Greens’ ... 'Green Budget' ... is more than just a Budget. It is their utopian vision for a different country. Unfortunately, it is also based on ludicrous assumptions and bad economics. ...

"The cornerstone of the Green revenue plan is a wealth tax raising $72.5 billion over four years. That is, well, optimistic. Just ask Germany, France and Sweden why they abandoned similar taxes. The reasons were capital flight, tax avoidance and administrative nightmares. ...

"Their plans for universal dental care ...is magical thinking, not policy. ...

"Their public housing plans ... offer no realistic plan for quadrupling construction capacity in a sector already facing severe workforce shortages and supply chain constraints.

"Their $395 weekly Income Guarantee ignores inevitable [inflationary] market responses. ... [guaranteeing] a return to similar inequality but with vastly higher government spending.

"The Greens have presented us with a textbook case of utopian thinking. And not coincidentally, 'utopia' literally means 'a place that does not exist'.”
~ Oliver Hartwich from his post ' The Green Budget fantasy'

Friday, 23 August 2024

Helen Clark is now *against* corruption!

 

Helen Clark's eponymous foundation has come out against corruption in politics, which is a bit like coming out in favour of apple pie with cream.  

As I outline below, you'd think an organisation using Ms Clark's name might stay quiet on the subject of corruption. What her foundation's report calls corruption however included in one neat package deal the putrid practices of political lobbyists, and the act of people donating to their favourite political party.

These are two very different things.

One has the stench of cronyism. Of peddlers of political relationships forming a parasite class that Ayn Rand once called an "aristocracy of pull." The other is, well, for the most part it is just people donating to a political party because they like the party's policies and/or people.

Yes, cause and effect sometimes goes the other way. There are parties who do sell policies to donors. The ACT party's pathetic capitulations to Auckland council amalgamation and on abolishing the RMA has for years been predicated upon the many consultants who donate to and infest the party, and who never see a trough they don't like. The National Party's silence on China's many misdeeds may be connected to large donations from organisations like the Inner Mongolia Rider Horse group. The link between Winstons First's racing and fishing policies and his racing and fishing donors is oft ignored simply because major parties seek a sweetheart deal with him every three years,  but is tangible, not to mention the link between Labour's policies (education policies for example, favouring teachers unions) and trades union donations of time and money to Labour's campaign. And not to mention all the "green" projects subsidised with taxpayer money to help out the businesses and of Green donors.

But for the most part, donations are small beer. And are fairly transparent. It's the hole-and-corner parasites of political pull who are the biggest evil. And they're everywhere.

PJ O’Rourke used to delight in pointing out that this corruption, the buying and selling of political favour, is simply the price of Big Government — the sort of government that Clark herself has always favoured. Favours for cronies. Jobs for the boys (and girls). Big Government's power and money on sale to the highest bidders.

No one should be surprised. As O'Rourke used to remind us, when legislation proscribes what is bought and sold, the first things to be bought will be the legislators -- and the more legislation is written the higher the demand, and the higher the price.

The answer of course is a separation of state and economy, in the same way and for much the same reasons as the separation of church and state.

But that is not what Clark's foundation prescribes. 

It's not what Clark herself is after.

Helen Clark and her followers have long favoured direct payment of political parties by taxpayers. That's what this is about. Taxpayers forced to donate to parties whose views they may abhor. To political parties whose power would only become more entrenched by the regular involuntary AP from taxpayers' pockets. Clark favours this because her own Red Team suffers by comparison with donations to the Blue Team. (Not that money on its own can win elections, otherwise the ACT Party would have been in power for the last three decades.)

This was the impetus behind then-Prime Minister Clark's infamous user of illegal taxpayer money for her own election campaigns — "illegal" was the Auditor-General's word — passing retrospective legislation to legalise what commentator Chris Trotter called "acceptable corruption." ("Acceptable" because it was his own favoured political regime ransacking the public purse.) And for then-Prime Minister Clark's subsequent passing of the Electoral Finance Act to muzzle her opponents during election campaigns.

Corruption? If there's anyone in New Zealand politics who knows about corruption it's Helen Clark. When I read that Helen Clark's Foundation is "targeting corruption," I immediately searched here at NOT PC for "Helen Clark corruption." It's quite a trove. It runs for three pages. if you feel like diving in, start with the post near the top: ' Cancerous and corrosive and un-democratic and, and, and ...

Or of you want a fuller story, download this PDF copy of The Free Radical from 2006 explaining, as the cover story describes 'How Labour Stole the Election.'