Showing posts with label MAGAts. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MAGAts. Show all posts

Thursday, 5 November 2026

"The GOP must be purged of the MAGA curse. Hopefully, the 2026 midterm slaughter of that party will prove to be the bitter medicine that achieves this exorcism."

Some decent commentary on The Wipeout:

The US has no idea the world of hurt that it has ushered. It is truly soul-crushing to see some of the outcomes. My reaction is not based on partisan politics but rather a deep love and reverence for the US. Regrettably, American Exceptionalism is increasingly disappearing. I will continue fighting in the battle of ideas but I fear that this might be a fatal inflection point. May the America of the Founding Fathers eventually prevail.
~ Gad Saad
[I]t’s clear that campaigning on affordability alone did not move the needle enough—not here, and not in a lot of districts. Yes, the price of gas hurt Trump and made many Democratic victories possible, but it was not enough to explain last night’s results.
    This is a actually a heartening result. I’ve heard a lot of bitterness about the prospect that Americans wouldn’t vote against Trump because of his tyrannical policies or disregard for constitutional rights, that they would only vote against him if it inconveniences them economically. The midterm election result seems to show the opposite.
    It gives us hope that the cultural forces that won the Civil Rights Movement are still alive and well, and we won’t all just bow down to a king because he hates the same people we hate. God bless America.

 

Far from saving Americans from socialism and the whackadoodle, economically illiterate left, Trump has fuelled their ascent to power - an ascent so quick and full that it was unimaginable just two years ago. Trump achieved this remarkable, horrible feat not by doggedly promoting free markets and constitutionally limited government but, instead, in part by revealing repeatedly to the American people that he has no use for such principles - or, indeed, for any principles at all.
    The other part of Trump's contribution to America's jolt toward collectivists-in-power is his obvious immaturity. No ordinary American would welcome such a clown as a neighbour. Every ordinary American cursed to have such an infantile bully for a neighbour would treat that neighbour as a curse, someone to avoid and to hope will soon move to another town - hopefully one far away.
    So, yes, in 2024 Trump 'had the libs.' But he, in his juvenile brain, didn't 'have the libs' in order to return America to a principled policy of limited government and free markets. He 'had the libs' as a sort of reality-show host selfishly interested only in getting a rise out of people with his ridiculous antics and schoolyard 'humour.'
    If America fifty years from now is as economically moribund as is today's Europe - not an unthinkable prospect - with property rights held in contempt and bureaucrats intruding into every aspect of Americans' lives and the Constitution a dead letter, a chief spark for this terrible fate will have been Trump. Fortunately for me, I'll not be around to witness this calamity.
    The GOP must be purged of the MAGA curse. Hopefully, the 2026 midterm slaughter of that party will prove to be the bitter medicine that achieves this exorcism. But no friend of liberty – no economically literate person – no American who understands and is committed to the liberal tradition that gave birth the the American nation – is pleased that the crop of illiberal (and indeed, in some cases openly anti-semitic) economic imbeciles who yesterday were voted into office will soon exercise power.
    But, hey, despite the collectivism enabled by Trump - and in no small part practiced by him - Americans in 2076 will have a gargantuan arch at which to gaze. So there's that.
~ Don Boudreaux
It’s more than the war: It’s Trump. The American people rejected Trump.
    They rejected Trump on the grounds of his handling of the war, yes — but moreover they rejected him (and by extension his party) for his constant distractions, distractions that everyone understood detracted from the fundamental reason that Trump got himself reelected. In 2024, Trump promised — no, he guaranteed — a return to low inflation and prosperity; he promised real wage growth; he promised cultural normality.
    Instead, the last two years have brought an air of shambolic chaos in Washington. Trump careened from 30 percent tariffs to a trade war with China to 10 percent across-the-board tariffs to a trade war on Canada to 100 percent tariffs on China to a potential invasion of Greenland to a real shooting war in the Persian Gulf. On top of all that, he called the 'affordability crisis' a hoax; he put his face on the coinage; he caterwauled about the Nobel Peace Prize; he spent an inordinate amount of time and energy on his White House ballroom and the grass on the National Mall and the trees surrounding public golf courses in D.C.; he spent the closing weeks of the campaign performatively describing the rear ends of Republican political candidates; he put internet-obsessed 14-year-olds in charge of the White House Twitter account.
    I’ve long thought that the true origins of the blue wave that crashed ashore this week were the Liberation Day tariffs of April 2025. But the issue, in my view, wasn’t tariffs per se — though the tariffs did put upward pressure on prices and that certainly didn’t help.
    I see the Liberation Day the same way that I see Joe Biden’s Afghanistan withdrawal debacle in the summer of 2021.
    Why? Afghanistan and Liberation Day were the precise moments when normie, not particularly partisan, not particularly tuned-in Americans looked up in horror and lost confidence that Biden and then Trump were capable of basic competence. Neither presidency ever recovered.
    If the economy were roaring throughout 2025, inflation was under control, and real wages were up, voters may have given Trump a little more leash on Iran and high gas prices in 2026. After all, while gas and diesel prices were painfully high, American combat troops weren’t dying in large numbers. But after the chaotic deployment of the tariffs in April 2025 and the economic shocks that resulted, voters simply weren’t going to do that.
    To be clear, the Iran war, especially the way it has been handled, especially the way that Trump constantly promised that victory was just around the corner (or was already in the bag), is not popular. But unpopular foreign wars don’t typically turn Texas into a blue state. Texas, after all, with its important oil and gas sector, has a lot to gain from consistently elevated energy prices. If the Iran war was so extremely unpopular as to come close to destroying the Republican Party as a viable electoral enterprise going forward, where were the massive street protests in the suburbs of Dallas and Houston?
    More convincingly, after eleven years as the dominant, completely unavoidable figure in the nation’s political life, the American people were sick of Donald Trump. On Tuesday, they showed him just how sick of him they were."
~ National Review's Mark Antonio Wright: 'It Was Trump, Stupid'
In fact, sheer exhaustion now defines the public’s responses to Trump, too. Many Americans who had a lot of tolerance for him and once found his antics entertaining are tired of it all. His silly nicknames and his petty whining haven’t gotten any dumber — they were always this dumb. But many people who thought they were funny have grown sick of them, and Trump’s sheer unseriousness now strikes some of his former supporters as inadequate to the office and the moment.
    That this exhaustion is what drove the midterm wave is crucial to understand if we want to learn some lessons from an election that harbours a lot of them.
    These lessons aren’t new, despite the scale of the outcome. There is always a tendency in the immediate wake of an election to see its results as a stark change of direction launching something wholly unprecedented. But it seems to me that the message of this election is pretty much the same as the message of all of our national elections for at least a decade now. The message is: 'No, thank you.'
    The American electorate has been repudiating the status quo again and again, but our political leaders have refused to offer something different. Trump’s election in 2016 was a rebuke of the increasingly culturally radical Democratic Party of Barack Obama’s final years. Joe Biden’s election in 2020 was a rebuke of Trump and his ridiculous approach to governing. But in its place, Biden offered a return to exactly what voters had rejected by electing Trump to begin with. So in 2024, voters rejected that cultural progressivism yet again, but all they were offered in its place was literally the return of Donald Trump. Now they’re rejecting that again, and presumably the next two years will only make them more eager to put it behind them.
    In each case, the public rendered a negative verdict on the loser, not a positive verdict on the winner. We have been living through what you might call a politics without winners."
~ National Review's Yuval Levin: 'Another Repudiation Election'
 
Vice President J.D. Vance and others in the Republican Party are reportedly trying to pin the blame for this result entirely on the war. 'The reason we lost is the war,' Vance told The New York Times on Wednesday—conveniently pinning all the blame on the one major Trump administration decision that he's questioned.
    But the tariffs are a major part of the story.
    Tariffs are Trump's signature economic policy. More than that, in fact. They have become the signature economic policy for the entire populist movement that has sprung up around Trump. The president promised a 'golden age,' and allies like Oren Cass and Peter Navarro promised a realignment that would bring working-class voters into the GOP for good.
    So how do Americans view this tentpole policy of the populist right?
    According to an NBC News exit poll of midterm voters, just 21 percent said the tariffs had helped the national economy. Even fewer voters, just 14 percent, said the tariffs had helped their local economies. Meanwhile, more than 60 percent said the tariffs had caused harm.
~ Eric Boehm, from his column 'How Did Republicans Lose This Badly? Voters Turned Against Trump's Tariffs.'

It's a wipeout

 

Yesterday's wipeout of the Republican ticket should be a message to MAGA -- that Americans have had enough of the presidential office being soiled. Of tariffs as threats, of executive power abuse, of debt soaring and liberties trampled on. Sadly, however, the MAGAts are too dumb to read the text. The Copium they're busy inhaling is that's all about petrol prices and "the Iran thing" ...

But it's still a wipeout.



More soon.

Here are the Surfaris...

Tuesday, 13 October 2026

Ukraine just destroyed a Russian bot farm. You won't believe what happened next!

 

Yes, a US president just announced an "energy ceasefire" in Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Unfortunately, he forgot to tell the combatants. ["They agreed because I said they agree.”] Putin celebrated by sending glide bombs into a children's playground. Ukraine meanwhile destroyed four Yandex data servers in Sasovo, Kaluga, Vladimir and Mytishchi, near Moscow.

The results were immediate. Hundreds of thousands of Russian bots sourced from the Yandex server died immediately. And the results of that can almost be seen from space:
And almost immediately, those bots died -- bots pretending to represent real people, purporting to be "patriots," "veterans," or "Christian conservative fathers"  -- usually with a follower count approaching zero and a user name running into at least 7 digits -- and all those posts supporting UK's Reform, Germany's AfD, and Trump's MAGAts suddenly fell off a cliff. 

The tide went out on the scam, at least for a moment. The Kremlin intelligence psyop that has been poisoning politics is exposed, and we can see which rotten political life has been swimming naked -- . .

And this is just as London's Times is preparing to report that Russia used over 150,000 Twitter accounts to influence the Brexit referendum; sent 45,000 tweets in 48 hours to influence the vote; and a Tory PM (Theresa May) knew there was interference and told Putin but not the British people!

In one night, Zelenskyy "single-handedly improved social media more than any governments have in years of legislation." As Megham McCarthy quipped, "I would pay Ukraine a monthly fee to keep blowing up Russian bots."

In one night, the Axis of Online Upheaval died -- and with it the manufactured support for the Axis of Upheaval itself.

And for a brief time we get to see the effect of the one major weapon Russia really has: the ability to disrupt the west with disinformation.

Naturally, folk have been checking and testing. Without bot traffic, check out for example the responses to the White House's latest ludicrous announcement. And see how this test went ...
And whatever your views about Twitter, or whatever the hell the owner wants to call it now, "where else can you see a Ukrainian drone manufacturer trolling Russian internet executives after blowing up their data centres?"

Monday, 19 January 2026

"Trump supporters continue to lie for him." [updated]

"Trump supporters continue to lie for him. Tariffs are not about fentanyl, national security, or even jobs.
    "They're about consolidating power for the sake of using it arbitrarily."

~ Keith Weiner

***

* * * * 


UPDATE:

"Trump’s demand to annex Greenland either through money or the military is becoming the catalyst for the possible destruction of the Atlantic Alliance. Trump could not do more to serve the geopolitical interests of Russia and China if he was an actual puppet of Moscow and Beijing."
~ Richard Ebeling

"As an American, I have one thing to say to my many European friends: Do not back down in this confrontation. Up to now, both the EU and the major European powers have sought to appease Trump by offering him concessions, flattery, personal gifts, and other forms of tribute. This strategy has not worked and should be abandoned immediately.

"Donald Trump is fundamentally a bully who wants to dominate everyone around him. Trying to placate him with concessions is a fool’s errand ...

"What makes any European think that conceding Greenland will mollify Trump? He will simply come back for more, later. ... [And a]t this point, Trump’s America has amply demonstrated that it will not be a reliable ally when push comes to shove. It has already abandoned Ukraine, and stated in November’s National Security Strategy that Europe has fallen behind the Western Hemisphere in terms of American priorities.  

"Europeans should keep in mind that those countries that stood up to Trump’s threats in 2025 ... all did well and did not have to succumb. ...

"It may be the case that the world will have to risk suffering a global recession as more countries stand up to Trump and retaliate against his policies. But a U.S. politician who wants to weaponise trade and use it as a lever for territorial expansion needs to be taught a painful lesson."

~ Francis Fukuyama from his column 'Don’t Back Down, Europe: Trump’s tariff threats against allies should be the last straw.'

Friday, 16 January 2026

"One of the main differences between this Trump Administration and the previous term: he is currently surrounded by people who take his craziest ideas and then come up with elaborate rationalisations for why he should do them."

"One of the main differences between this Trump Administration and the previous term: ... the adults from the first term either said 'enough' after Jan 6th and walked away, or they found themselves driven out because they refused to budge on one or more of Trump's craziest ideas.

"That means the 2nd term self-selected for people who, through their own lack of virtue, are unbothered by the ethical failures of the first term, and people who are True Believers (tm) in the craziest schemes of Trumpism today. Or both. ...

"[So h]e is currently surrounded by people who take his craziest ideas and then come up with elaborate rationalisations for why he should do them.

"Trump wants tariffs on everyone and everything? 'You know, Mr. President, there's this law called IEEPA...'

"Trump proposes some bonkers scheme to invade Greenland because he wants to make the country larger? 'You know, Mr. President, Greenland is actually important for US national security...'

"In the previous Administration, there were at least a few adults who shut down the wackiest impulses of Trump or deflected them to other areas. Now, flattering Trump's wackiest impulses is a pathway to promotion."
~ Phil Magness
"The adults in his previous term were people who believed in real governance—whether one liked their particular ideological or policy leanings or not—and thought Trump could be moderated with intelligent guidance. They were patriotic people who wanted to serve their country whether or not they approved of who has been elected.

"This time, every adult knew Trump could not be moderated, that they could not effectively serve their country, but could only support the crazy or be destroyed. So the stayed away in droves.

"And of course that suited Trump just fine. The first time around he was uncertain, and he wanted the patina of serious expert people around him. But he chafed at not being able to control them, and he came to realise all he needed (personally, with certainty, and possibly politically) was the continued adoration of the MAGA crowd. So he has been happy to not have any qualified people on board, but to have sycophants who both inflate his ego and keep the MAGA folks swooning in political ecstasy.

"And the adults are just sitting by thinking about whether an actual seizure of power through cancelled or rigged elections is [possible], and how to prevent it if there's a real danger of it, and how to restore some sanity, decency, and global trust when this passes."

Wednesday, 14 January 2026

'Trump’s Gestapo is now murdering protestors'

"ICE is Trump's Gestapo or SS. They have no proper function, no constitutional authorisation, and are loyal to Trump personally. ... (My use of 'Gestapo' is figurative. Literally, ICE is the transition to that kind of evil agency.) ...

"In Minneapolis on Wednesday, an ICE agent murdered a woman in her car. ... Trump’s goon squad, created out of xenophobia, shot a non-violent protestor three times in the face, killing her. ...

"The next day another shooting by federal border patrol agents (not ICE) occurred in Portland. ...

"Trump has claimed that the [murdered] victim was part of a 'far Left' network. Even if true, which I've heard no evidence to support, how does that justify killing her? If far Left organisations are protesting ICE and deportations, good for them.

"The two young people shot in Portland were not killed and are in the hospital. The Trump line is that they were part of a criminal drug gang and were here illegally. Drug gangs exist only because of the drug Prohibition. There are no Gatorade gangs, no chocolate bar cartels. Why not? Because these things are not illegalised and their prices are such as earn an average rate of profit. ...

"The [American] public's wrong view of immigrants and wrong ideas regarding drugs are enabling a power-mad low-life to change America into a police state.

"The public's wrong view could not have happened without the destruction of the concept of individual rights. ..."
~ Harry Binswanger from his post 'Trump’s Gestapo is now murdering protestors'

Monday, 12 January 2026

"Tyranny is the exercise of power beyond right, which no body can have a right to."


"As usurpation is the exercise of power, which another hath a right to; so tyranny is the exercise of power beyond right, which no body can have a right to. And this is making use of the power any one has in his hands, not for the good of those who are under it, but for his own private separate advantage ....

"[T]here is only one thing which gathers people into seditious commotion, and that is oppression. ...

"[W]henever the Legislators endeavour to take away, and destroy the Property of the People, or to reduce them to Slavery under Arbitrary Power, they put themselves into a state of War with the People, who are thereupon absolved from any farther Obedience, and are left to the common Refuge ... against Force and Violence. Whensoever therefore the Legislative shall transgress this fundamental Rule of Society; and either by Ambition, Fear, Folly or Corruption, endeavour to grasp themselves, or put into the hands of any other an Absolute Power over the Lives, Liberties, and Estates of the People; By this breach of Trust they forfeit the Power, the People had put into their hands, for quite contrary ends, and it devolves to the People, who have a Right to resume their original Liberty ... "
~ John Locke from his Second Treatise of Government

Friday, 14 November 2025

"MAGA, a movement built around the personality of one man, never amounted to a coherent political force or even a workable coalition."

"As in his first term, Donald Trump now presides over a visibly sinking ship as his approval ratings slide. MAGA, a movement built around the personality of one man, never amounted to a coherent political force or even a workable coalition. Claims that Trump and his lieutenants won a mandate in 2024 and then ‘saved’ the country were always delusional. …

"The ideological divide within MAGA has grown increasingly harsh. Trump is not, at heart, a professional politician. Rather, he is a blend of New York developer and carnival barker. His uneasy alliance with ‘tech bros’, Wall Street insiders and fervent right-wing nativists was never stable. It was held together mostly by Trump himself – and by the awfulness of the Democrats.

"Even as he strikes a populist pose, some people influential in MAGA flirt with ideas like eugenic Darwinism and a permanent ruling aristocracy. Others within MAGA embrace isolationism and attacks on minorities, particularly Jews. Trump rejects such notions, but too many top GOP figures ... seem terrified of alienating the odious Tucker Carlson ... 

"At its worst, MAGA’s hardest faction embraces openly racist groups such as the Proud Boys. There’s also a class element at play. Carlson, himself a product of the upper class, claims to speak for what he sees as ‘core’ Americans – basically middle-class white people – some of whom view immigration and cultural change as existential threats.

"Sadly, this faction [under Vance] could define MAGA after Trump. … even though Trump’s policies may shape the nation’s direction for years, a bit like an unpleasant but necessary [sic] enema. Unless the GOP rediscovers its Reaganite optimism and turns from vengeance to economic renewal, America’s future will likely belong either to the radical socialists or to the oligarch-friendly technocrats. Neither of which would be a desirable outcome."
~ Joel Kotkin from his post 'This is how MAGA falls'

Tuesday, 4 November 2025

"Interestingly, the right didn’t take the leftist ideas that were intended to build something; they took just the ideas intended to destroy."

"As so many have noted, MAGA is identity politics for white people. It turns out that identity politics is more effective when your group is in the majority.

"… Last year, a writer named James Lindsay cribbed language from “The Communist Manifesto,” changed its valences so that they were right wing and submitted it to a conservative publication called The American Reformer. The editors, unaware of the provenance, were happy to print it. When the hoax was revealed, they were still happy! The right is now eager to embrace the ideas that led to tyranny, the gulag and Mao’s Cultural Revolution. Interestingly, the right didn’t take the leftist ideas that were intended to build something; they took just the ideas intended to destroy."

~ David Brooks from his column 'Hey, Lefties! Trump Has Stolen Your Game' [hat tip Alex Tabarrok ] 

Tuesday, 1 July 2025

MAGA: "Empathy is out. Assholery is in."


How do you describe the rise of a creature like Trump. Jeffrey Tucker, Robert Bidinotto and Robert Tracinski tracked his early ascent— along with the parallel rise of the alt-right, which simply took the unthinking opposite side, however horrendous, of mainstream issues, without abandoning the collectivism that underpinned them. And the mainstream is still trying to explain MAGAts sufficiently deranged by Trump to follow him so blindly. Doug Muder identifies several "rifts" in American culture that he's lucked into exploiting.
Donald Trump, in my opinion, is not some history-altering mutant, like the Mule in Asimov’s 'Foundation' trilogy. I think of him as an opportunist who exploited rifts in American society and weak spots in American culture. He did not create those rifts and weak spots, and ... they will still be there waiting for their next exploiter. ...
The first rift he identifies is The Rift Between Working and Professional Classes, i.e., between "the people who shower after work and the people who shower before work."
All through Elon Musk’s political ascendancy, I kept wondering: How can working people possibly believe that the richest man in the world is on their side? Similarly, how can people who unload trucks or operate cash registers imagine that Donald Trump, who was born rich and probably never did a day of physical labor in his life, is their voice in government?

The answer to that question is simple: The people who shower after work have gotten so alienated from the people who shower before work that anyone who takes on “the educated elite” seems to be their ally. In the minds of many low-wage workers, the enemy is not the very rich, but rather the merely well-to-do — people with salaries and benefits and the ability to speak the language of bureaucracy and science.

Actual billionaires like Musk or Trump or Jeff Bezos or Mark Zuckerberg are so distant that it’s hard to feel personally threatened by them. But your brother-in-law the psychologist or your cousin who got an engineering degree — you know they look down on you. Whenever they deign to discuss national affairs with you at all, it’s in that parent-to-child you-don’t-really-understand tone of voice. And let’s not even mention your daughter who comes home from college with a social justice agenda. Everything you think is wrong, and she can’t even explain why without using long words you’ve never heard before. Somebody with a college degree is telling you what to do every minute of your day, and yet you’re supposed to be the one who has “privilege”.

The tension has been building for a long time, but it really boiled over for you during the pandemic. You couldn’t go to work, your kids couldn’t go to school, you couldn’t go to football games or even to church — and why exactly? Because “experts” like Anthony Fauci were “protecting” you from viruses too small to see. (They could see them, but you couldn’t. Nothing you could see interested anybody.) Then there were masks you had to wear and shots you had to get, but nobody could explain exactly what they did. Would they keep you from getting the disease or transmitting it to other people? Not exactly. If you questioned why you had to do all this, all they could do was trot out statistics and point to numbers. And if you’ve learned anything from your lifetime of experience dealing with educated people, it’s that they can make numbers say whatever they want. The “experts” speak maths and you don’t, so you just have to do what they say.
Can we say we haven't seen that same thing here? 
In his 2012 book 'The Twilight of the Elites,' Chris Hayes outlined the ways that the expert class has become self-serving. In theory, the expert class is comprised of winners in a competitive meritocracy. But in practice, educated professionals have found ways to tip the balance in their children’s favor. Also, the experts did not do a good job running the Iraq or Afghanistan wars, and they failed to foresee the economic crisis of 2008. When they did notice it, they responded badly: Bankers got bailed out while many ordinary people lost their homes. ... 
On the public-trust side, people have been too willing to believe conspiracy theories about perfectly legitimate things like the Covid vaccine [and to applaud the appointment of an anti-vaccine loony to the job of Health Secretary]. Trump’s slashing of funding for science and research is a long-term disaster for America, and his war against top universities like Harvard and Columbia destroys one of the major advantages the US has on the rest of the world. But many cheer when revenge is taken on the so-called experts they think look down on them.
There are many genuine reasons to mistrust the people we see so frequently wheeled out by media and government as so-called experts. But you'd be a fool to abandon trust in genuine expertise—or to place that trust instead in know-nothing figureheads like a Trump or a Bannon or (closer to home) to a Winston, Tamaki or the like. 

The next rift he identifies however opens up in this era of Post-Truth Politics. Muder calls it Truth Decay, that realisation that in the marketplace of ideas, truth no longer matters. Post-modernism has won. The mainstream media's peddling opinion has betrayed their prior responsibility to just report the facts — both science and media have been corrupted by government money — and now reality is biting back in the form of a loss of public trust.
And now too many public figures neither know nor care. About anything. And certainly not about facts. Only a short while ago a Libertarian presidential candidate with unusually decent momentum was drummed out of the campaign by not knowing "What's Aleppo?" No, a Republican senator can confuse “gazpacho” with “Gestapo” and no-one blinks an eye.
Along with the lost of trust in experts and the inability of American society to agree on a basic set of facts, we are plagued by a loss of depth in our public discussions. It’s not just that Americans don’t know or understand things, it’s that they’ve lost the sense that there are things to know or understand. College professors report that students don’t know how to read entire books any more. And we all have run into people who think they are experts on a complex subject (like climate change or MRNA vaccines) because they watched a YouTube video.

Levels of superficiality that once would have gotten someone drummed out of politics — [like a Defence Secretary's inability to answer a straight question, or the Attorney General's ignorance of the separation of powers, or the president's complete incomprehension of the Constitution he had sworn only weeks before to defend and protect] — are now everyday events.

So the MAGAts have captured the low ground. For now. They've become the swamp. But in the absence of any coherent programme, all they have is pissing off their opponents. Making liberals cry. Essentially, at the end of the rot, what we are left with is this: Empathy is out. Assholery is in. Basically, when the rubber of MAGAt policies hit the road, they're intended to hit someone. "The cruelty is the point. MAGA means never having to say you’re sorry. If people you don’t like are made poorer, weaker, or sicker — well, good! Nothing tastes sweeter than liberal tears."

We can hear the spectacle of cruel laughter throughout the Trump era. There were the border-patrol agents cracking up at the crying immigrant children separated from their families, and the Trump adviser who delighted white supremacists when he mocked a child with Down syndrome who was separated from her mother. There were the police who laughed uproariously when the president encouraged them to abuse suspects, and the Fox News hosts mocking a survivor of the Pulse Nightclub massacre (and in the process inundating him with threats), the survivors of sexual assault protesting to Senator Jeff Flake, the women who said the president had sexually assaulted them, and the teen survivors of the Parkland school shooting. There was the president mocking Puerto Rican accents shortly after thousands were killed and tens of thousands displaced by Hurricane Maria, the black athletes protesting unjustified killings by the police, the women of the #MeToo movement who have come forward with stories of sexual abuse, and the disabled reporter whose crime was reporting on Trump truthfully. It is not just that the perpetrators of this cruelty enjoy it; it is that they enjoy it with one another. Their shared laughter at the suffering of others is an adhesive that binds them to one another, and to Trump.
And that was all just Trump's first term! It's already got much worse.

It’s hard to look at any list of recent Trump administration actions without concluding that these people are trying to be assholes. It’s not an accident. It’s not a side effect of something else. The assholery is the point.
In the absence of anything else of positive substance, that's really all there is.

Thursday, 29 May 2025

What era does MAGAts' 'greatness' refer to?

Trump as Napoleon. Not a real photo.
"Policies come and go, allies are cast out as enemies and then welcomed back ... thing[s] may change from the beginning of a speech to the end. But the slogan never changes: Make America Great Again. It’s been so steady that everyone knows it just by its initials, MAGA. You talk about MAGA followers or the MAGA Party [or MAGAts] , and everyone knows what you mean. ...

"And yet, every day we see Trump tear down the things that have made America great ... What era does 'greatness' refer to?

"Look at some of the things Trump thinks will make America 'great again' and ask yourself what era they belong to. ['Great again'? When exactly?] Invariably, they fit a Napoleonic view of greatness, not a 21st-century view: Territorial expansion. ... Mercantile dominance ... Manliness ... A Great Leader. ...

"But think for a minute about what has made America great these last hundred years: Science.... Trustworthy institutions... The rule of law... Education... Alliances and treaties... Immigration... Moral leadership... Freedom....

"Now look at what the Trump administration has been doing. ...
"So is Trump pursuing national greatness? Yes, but according to a notion of greatness that passed its sell-by date centuries ago. He aspires to a Napoleonic greatness and is oblivious to everything that makes a 21st-century nation great. ..."
~ Doug Muder from his post 'The Greatness Paradox'

Wednesday, 30 April 2025

"Nationalism is often its own worst enemy"

"I’ve been very discouraged by the global rise in nationalism. But there is one glimmer of hope. Nationalism is often its own worst enemy. ...

"In yesterday’s election in Canada, we saw an almost perfect example of ... the internal contradictions of global nationalism.

“'[Conservative leader Pierre] Poilievre had been running a disciplined and effective campaign which had him with a 25-point lead in our final poll of 2024, ... But suddenly everything was 'radically disrupted' by several factors ... the 'most important' disruption for Poilievre was the 'visceral recoil' Canadians felt when they heard Trump talk about annexation. ...

"'A wave of nationalism swept the country, with Canadians booing the American national anthem at hockey games, boycotting U.S. products, and all but abandoning cross-border travel.

"'This put Poilievre in a near-impossible position. Much of his base—including many of his MPs—admire Trump. But with Trump openly attacking Canada, and with Poilievre’s own anti-woke rhetoric and disdain for the mainstream media, he found himself trapped. Attempts to distance himself from Trump could alienate core supporters, while embracing the American president would push away everyone else.'

"I would argue that the single most consequential action of President Trump’s first 100 days (for better or worse) was his trade war with Canada, which clearly prevented the election of a Conservative administration. Before the trade war, the Conservatives were set to win by a historic landslide.

"Next up, Australia: ... [where] the prospect of conservative opposition leader Peter Dutton winning power was 'very frightening' [said one voter], after seeing the disruption caused by Donald Trump in the United States'."

~ Scott Sumner, composite quote from his posts 'Global nationalism?' and 'Global nationalism: Part 2'

Tuesday, 8 April 2025

"Tariffs Aren’t Liberating": Your Tuesday Tariffs Ramble [UPDATED]

UPDATE: Some more great links here curated by Don Boudreaux, to help you put this calamity on context.

Since it's the topic of the day a historic turning point in human affairs, the least I can do is offer readers a ramble around the topic of tariffs and the destruction of tariff wars — basically, around the many writers reciting the multiplicity of ways in which the Trump Administration has fucked us.

"“Liberation Day”: That is what US President Donald Trump has called Wednesday, April 2, the day he announced huge swaths of taxes on imports worldwide. Despite the label, it was far from a day of liberation. By making imports to the US more expensive, the government is actively increasing the cost of living for American consumers.
    "The Trump administration has fallen for one of the most common misconceptions about trade—that it only benefits a country when it is the exporter. This could not be further from the truth. One of the greatest benefits of free trade lies with the importing country, where consumers gain access to a huge range of goods, crucially, at lower prices.
    "Whether it’s clothes, food, medical supplies, or mobile phones, access to the global market reduces the cost of living and increases consumer choice, often alleviating poverty in the process.
    "It comes down to a very simple principle. No one person could produce everything he or she consumes. No family or household could do so either. No city, town, or province could produce absolutely everything they consume. Equally, no country can produce everything it consumes, nor should it. Attempts to achieve autarky are acts of economic self-harm. Freedom to exchange across borders is win-win: it allows consumers to access a plethora of goods and services, improving welfare overall."
Tariffs Aren’t Liberating - Reem Ibrahim, FOUNDATION FOR ECONOMIC EDUCATION

"Tariffs are irrational both morally and practically.
    "Morally, tariffs are rights violations - they restrain or prohibit individuals from trading freely and voluntarily in their own self-interest with whomever - no matter where they reside geographically. ...
    "Practically, tariffs punish the individuals in the country which implements them. Trump even acknowledges the pain. But he mystically thinks this pain will be good and lead us to prosperity.
    "Tariffs raise prices, cause shortages, and decrease productivity. They destroy wealth, businesses, income, and jobs. This is well known in theory and practice. See the Smoot-Hawley Act and its role in making the Great Depression even worse.
    "Trump’s foreign policy is morally and practically irrational.
    "What is the moral and practical foreign policy solution?
    "Free trade."
          ~ Andy Clarkson

"The essence of capitalism's foreign policy is free trade—i.e., the abolition of trade barriers, of protective tariffs, of special privileges—the opening of the world's trade routes to free international exchange and competition among the private citizens of all countries dealing directly with one another."
The Roots of War - Ayn Rand, ARI CAMPUS


"Fundamental to the argument for high tariffs has been the argument that trade deficits reflect America being "exploited" or "taken advantage of." In this article of mine on, "Why Trade Deficits Don't Matter -- Unless Caused by Government," I explain the misguided economic reasoning behind this claim, and why the far better policy is free trade."
Trade Deficits Don’t Matter – Unless Caused by Government - Richard Ebeling, FUTURE OF FREEEDOM FOUNDATION

"Donald Trump is fond of saying that trade wars are easy to win. Among the litany of patently false Trumpisms, this may well prove one of the most disastrous. ...
    "Protective tariffs risk triggering a cycle of escalation that ends well for no one."
No One Wins a Trade War - William Bernstein, THE ATLANTIC

"America can’t be outcompeted because America does not produce or trade anything.
     "Nations do not compete with nations. Individual firms compete with individual firms abroad. Ford competes with Toyota. America does not compete with Japan. Nations are trading partners, not competitors."
Why America can't be outcompeted - Harry Binswanger, HARRY'S SUBSTACK




"“We are seeing a combination of true-believing mercantilism, shocking ignorance about how the global economy works, and shocking incompetence in the planning and execution of economic policy,” says Michael Strain."
Trump's aggressive push to roll back globalisation -FINANCIAL TIMES (paywall0

"Like the post-1945 British Labour governments, he wants to shelter domestic manufacturing and the working class behind tariffs while reducing overseas commitments. But the net result will be both economically damaging and geopolitically weakening. Americans will come to miss globalism and policing the world. They will belatedly realise that there is no portal through which the United States can return to the 1950s, much less the 1900s. And the principal beneficiary of Project Minecraft will not be Russia, but China. Call it Project Manchuria. ... 
"The president stands as much chance of reindustrialising the U.S. as you do of getting your frozen laptop to work by smashing the motherboard with a Minecraft hammer."
Trump’s Tariffs and the End of American Empire - Niall Ferguson, THE FREE PRESS

"So think of it as a world wide Brexit like the U.S. leaving the global economy.
    "A trade lawyer at a global law firm here in London told me their clients see Trump’s tariffs as “worse than Brexit” as they’re dealing with rapidly changing trade rules on a massive scale. It’s not just the tariffs that Trump has imposed, but the retaliation it will provoke."
‘How Ugly Is This Going to Be?’ - Graham Lanktree, POLITICO


"It sounds so sensible: why not use protection and industrial policy to preserve manufacturing capacity “just in case” of, say, a war or a pandemic? And, to be sure, this is a better argument for some limited government intervention on trade and investment flows than wanting to tax imported bananas or revive manufacturing.
    "But even then it’s not the slam dunk some people imagine. Below is my chapter on this issue from Economics In One Virus, published in 2021. It’s just as true and relevant today."

"The populist story of the death of U.S. manufacturing is nonsense. Mr. Vance and his cohort maintain that increased free trade with countries such as China in 2000 or Mexico in 1994 killed American jobs. It’s true that the number of manufacturing jobs is lower than it was in 1970. But that’s because we can make so much more with fewer people. Blame technology, not trade.
    "Real hourly output per manufacturing employee has been on an upward trend since 1959. Real U.S. manufacturing value-added—the sector’s contribution to gross domestic product—reached its highest recorded level in 2022. Manufacturing output was close to its all-time high in 2022, and the U.S. remained the global leader in manufacturing value-added per worker.
    "Steel is one example. In 1980, one steelworker could produce 0.083 tons of steel in one hour. By 2018, one steelworker could produce 1.67 tons in an hour. This is a good thing. Wage and income data in the U.S. show the rising tide is lifting all boats—especially the smallest.
    "Americans don’t want their children to have to work punishing jobs in a steel mill, and it’s evident they don’t have to. Manufacturing jobs, as a share of total employment, have been on a downward trend since 1943—falling from 39% to under 25% by the end of 1970 and hitting 20% in 1980. This decline started long before Ronald Reagan ran for office, before China received Most Favored Nation status for outsourcing manufacturing, before Bill Clinton signed the North American Free Trade Agreement and before the World Trade Organization was created. The trends even started five years before the U.S. joined the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade."
Free Trade Didn’t Kill the Middle Class - Norbert J. Michel, WALL STREET JOURNAL
“The philosophy of protectionism is a philosophy of war.”
          ~ Ludwig von Mises
"“When it comes to steel, it’s fantastic for our industry,” said Jack Maskil [president of the United Steelworkers Local 2227 in Pittsburgh’s Mon Valley], “but what about everything else?” ...
    "On the one hand, they are thrilled that their industry will be a key beneficiary of the 25 percent tariff imposed on steel imports to the U.S. ...
    "But while the steelworkers are also hoping that tariffs will bring about a revival of manufacturing jobs, they also worry about their effect on the economy, and on their own purchasing power."

"President Trump’s ‘Liberation Day’ tariffs risk domino effect across the globe as Chinese goods look for new markets."


"The proponents of protectionism say, “Free trade is fine in theory but it must be reciprocal. We cannot open our markets to foreign products if foreigners close their markets to us.” China, they argue, to use their favorite whipping boy, “keeps her vast internal market for the private domain of Chinese industry but then pushes her products into the U.S. market and complains when we try to prevent this unfair tactic.”
    "The argument sounds reasonable. It is, in fact, utter nonsense. Exports are the cost of trade, imports the return from trade, not the other way around."


"This idea that Donald Trump is just playing hardball to negotiate tariff rates down on US exports is absolutely ridiculous. The % of tariffs applied to US-produced goods has declined consistently since WW2 and was nearly nothing...
    "UNTIL! Donald's first term, and now his second.
    "And yet I keep seeing so many MAGA supporters saying: 'We're already seeing countries backing down from their tariffs!'
    "You're literally winning a battle and losing the war at the same time ..."

"Then there’s Trump’s fascination with tariffs. The damage Trump has caused Ukraine and Nato pales by comparison to what his tariffs will do to America’s economy and the entire international economic system. If Trump had acted on April 1 instead of 2, he could quickly have said it was all an April Fool’s Day joke, thereby saving the global economy trillions of dollars of damage when markets started heading south. Unfortunately however, Trump is totally serious, a fact evident long before “Liberation Day.”
    "Here too, “experts” and anxious businesspeople steadfastly ignored Trump labelling “tariff” the dictionary’s most beautiful word. Tariffs, they said, will be targeted, carefully calibrated, and he’ll do deals quickly. It’s all a bargaining tactic, Treasury Secretary Bessent said in October, 2024: “escalate to de-escalate”. Even as global stock markets drop like rocks, experts are still rationalising what his “strategy” is.
    "Wrong again. Trump is more likely to win the Nobel Prize for literature than for peace."
I worked for Donald Trump. This is the key to understanding him: It’s not about America, and there’s no connection to the real world - John Bolton, TELEGRAPH (UK)
"Reminder: This policy was spearheaded and implemented by a man who thinks nobody says the word “groceries” these days because “it’s an old-fashioned word” and he somehow brought it back into the limelight.
    "Donald Trump is a motherfucking moron. Those who knew this and voted for him anyway because he gave them explicit license to be assholes deserve every last bit of pain his policies will cause them."
          ~ Stephen T. Stone
"In times of upheaval, those closest to power often find ways to turn disruption into wealth. Trump’s erratic tariff wars, billed as economic nationalism, upended markets, collapsed sectors, and triggered retaliatory shocks. But while farmers went bankrupt and consumers paid more, the market opened space for those with foresight—or insider access—to buy low and consolidate.
    "Geographer David Harvey calls this accumulation by dispossession: crisis used not to correct the system, but to extract from it. Devalue public assets. Destabilise protections. Create just enough chaos to buy cheap what others are forced to abandon. It’s not just policy failure—it’s extraction dressed as populism.
    "The con isn’t just psychological. It’s material. It’s not just about being lied to—it’s about being looted.
    "And that’s what makes this moment different—and more dangerous. The scam isn’t happening outside the system. It’s running through it."


"The latest rumor, when I started drafting this column, was that President Trump will suspend the tariffs for a 90-day period, with the exception of those on China. Markets started going back up again.
    "But “the very latest information” doesn’t stay current for long these days. The new report—but don’t count on it—is that the 90-day pause is not real after all. That revision came out before this draft was finished. And markets again whipsawed.
    "The Trump administration has created a new monster—one of unpredictability and erratic behavior. We simply cannot predict with any degree of accuracy what will happen next. By the time you are reading this article, there will probably be some newer report about the tariffs or threat of tariffs, and then another report after that.
    "Even if the White House winds up instituting a pause on the proposed tariffs—or ultimately adopts much better economic policies—this seesawing may plunge the American and perhaps also the global economy into recession."
A Contagion of Uncertainty - Tyler Cowen, THE FREE PRESS


[WATCH] Singapore must be clear-eyed about dangers ahead: Singapore's Prime Minister Wong on implications of US tariffs:

"Donald Trump has demonstrated his profound misunderstanding of the basic economic principles of international trade for several years now, and perhaps reached a pinnacle when he told the New York Daily News in an interview last August that “we’re getting hosed by the Chinese — and that we’ve done it with our eyes wide shut.” ...
    "[Trump adviser] Peter Navarro, in his Wall Street Journal opinion piece earlier this week (see related post here) demonstrated his fundamental misunderstanding of international trade when he opened his op-ed with the following question: “Do trade deficits matter?” Just to ask the question is to admit one’s ignorance of trade theory, which has been pretty settled on this topic since Adam Smith taught us in 1776 that “Nothing…can be more absurd than this whole doctrine of the balance of trade. ..."

Tariffs are a suicide bomb":

Trump's team said they based their "reciprocal tariff" calculation for each country based on the tariffs and impediments put on American imports by those countries. But no. It's even more irrational: "[Trump's chart] features an estimate of 'Tariffs Charged to the USA' by other countries that nobody could figure out, until a financial journalist realised it was just how much we export to that country, minus how much we import, divided by how much we import."



"Under a system of perfectly free commerce, each country naturally devotes its capital and labour to such employments as are most beneficial to each. This pursuit of individual advantage is admirably connected with the universal good of the whole. By stimulating industry, by regarding ingenuity, and by using most efficaciously the peculiar powers bestowed by nature, it distributes labour most effectively and most economically: while, by increasing the general mass of productions, it diffuses general benefit, and binds together by one common tie of interest and intercourse, the universal society of nations throughout the civilised world."
        ~ David Ricardo (1817)




"Why is today’s Trump so different from the Trump of his first term? .. ". Turns out, the answer is very simple" Back then he had people, and a Congress who would say "No." But now the yes men are in power.

Trump's tariffs policy came from his economic advisor Peter Navarro, who invented a fake expert in his books to justify it. "Peter Navarro liked to quote a guy named Ron Vara in his books. Those books are largely what led to Navarro becoming a top adviser to President Trump and helping to shape U.S. policy on China. Here’s the thing about Ron Vara, though: He doesn’t exist. ...
"Ron Vara is an anagram of Navarro."
Trump's China Muse Has an Imaginary Friend - Tom Bartlett, CHRONICLE OF HIGHER EDUCATION


 

Second-term Trump is who Trump always was. This is Trump without many adults in the room stopping him getting his way. This is Trump surronded by Yes Men in a cult. This is Trump. A freedom-hating, dictator-loving, trade-despising child who wants the power of a tryant. Someone who has no regard for facts and who will utter any lie he wishes - no matter how ridicolous it is. And his believers are expected to believe it. Under fear of discommunication from the cult.
This is what you asked for when you voted for Trump. This is what you got. I hope you are happy....
          ~ Dwayne Davies

"An often forgotten truth is that it is not just military warfare that can cause injury to innocent bystanders, the same inescapably happens in economic warfare initiated by governments, as well. But in the latter case the human “collateral damage” is a targetted victim. ...
    "Tariffs and counter-tariffs are tools of economic warfare that are said to be targeting the “aggressor” country. But the very nature of how tariffs and counter-tariffs work, results in the main targets being innocent bystanders in the countries concerned.
    "Once we disaggregate “nations” into their, respective, individual buyers and sellers, producers and consumers, we see that the most damage falls on the economic “non-combatants,” of whatever the original “dispute” may be about ..."
Trump’s Economic Warfare Targets Innocent Bystanders - Richard Ebeling, FUTURE OF FREEDOM FOUNDATION

"TikTok is a major bargaining chip in a grave geopolitical struggle. Given the data users have always sent to Beijing, it’s been a bargaining chip ever since it arrived on America’s digital shores. For Trump, though, it’s not exactly his chip to bargain with: Congress already determined the American course of action. The mystery is why nobody seems to mind Trump delaying its execution — or at least, why nobody is complaining publicly....
    "Trump’s motives here are not difficult to parse, and the bill in question is legitimately problematic. He’s popular on TikTok, and close to one of the company’s major investors. ...
    "As fallout continued from his tariff bombshell — including the legitimacy of his emergency authority to implement the new rates — barely anyone batted an eye at TikTok getting another dubious bailout."
Why Trump keeps saving TikTok - Emily Jashinsky, UNHERD

"Since my last essay on the crisis of democracy, the assaults on democratic checks and balances have escalated. Without agreement from Congress, Trump’s DOGE shut down the U.S. Agency for International Development with stunning speed. Although a federal court blocked further implementation, ruling that the action “likely violated the Constitution,” by then the agency had already been gutted and largely dismantled along with many other agenices. Then, in an alarming politicisation of the military high command, Trump fired the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, the Chief of Naval Operations, the Air Force Vice Chief of Staff, and the judge advocates general (the highest-ranking legal authorities) for the Army, Navy, and Air Force.
    "Pressing his claim to imperial power, Trump has moved to assert absolute control over all federal regulatory bodies, including the Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal Trade Commission, and the Federal Communications Commission. This not only hobbles their capacity to act independently in the public interest but opens the door to massive corruption. As DOGE seizes control of more and more of the government’s most sensitive and highly centralised stores of data, the conflicts of interest proliferate for its chief 'overseer,' Elon Musk, who over the years has received 'at least $38 billion in government contracts, loans, subsidies and tax credits.' And Just Security has documented an 'alarming' pattern of 'politicisation and weaponisation of the Department of Justice since Trump has retaken office.
    "The United States now faces the grave and imminent danger of its democracy decaying into a 'competitive authoritarianism'.”





"We have to realise that Trump is not joking about any of this. He’s not joking about invading Greenland, and he’s not joking about running for a third term. He’s as serious about all of this as he was about the tariffs. The evidence indicates that he will do it all, whatever he can get away with. ...
"While we prepare a mass movement—and Donald Trump crashing the economy with the world’s stupidest tariffs will help us a great deal—we need to fight everything. What that will specifically mean is that we have to fight a lot of losing battles. ...
"There are five reasons to fight early and often, no matter the odds of winning any one fight.
    1. It lays down a marker. ....
    2. It mobilises others to fight. ....
    3. It delays and exhausts the strongman. ...
    4. Sometimes you win. ...
    5. You find out what works and who fights. ...."
How to Fight Back - Robert Tracinski, TRACINSKI LETTER