Monday, May 17, 2010

What tax cuts?

The spin has already been spotted in the wild, and by Budget Day this week the spin will be a tsunami.

I"m talking about the lie of tax cuts--the tax cuts that were promised before the election in the face of world economic collapse; the tax cuts the promise of which was broken because this government lacked the courage to  deliver the necessary spending cuts to match them; the “tax cuts” that are now being signalled in return for increases in GST, tobacco and alcohol taxes, and “carbon taxes” on power and petrol.

I’m talking about the spin that the few cuts, which will be more than outweighed by the increases, are somehow a return on that broken election promise. To that I say, “Bullshit!” The only “tax cuts” you’ll see are those with tax hikes that more than make up for that little. 

    “Look, over there; it looks like a tax cut.”
    “And look, over there; there’s a tax hike to match.”

At a time this government spends every week a quarter-of-a-billion more than it takes in, it shows no intention of stemming this fatal haemorrhage of red ink.  That is just one measure of its irresponsibility.

A measure of its duplicity is the gap between what was promised, i.e., real tax cuts, and what is being delivered, i.e., no real tax cuts--and to whom promises were kept and to whom they were broken.

The credibility gap is huge. There will be no tax cuts.  Today in New Zealand it’s finally “Tax Freedom Day”—the day when the median New Zealander stops working for the government and starts earning for him or herself. That day occurs later in the year here than it does in Australia, the US, or even the deeply troubled UK—and that day has not been moved back one iota by this government, but forwards in order to help bankroll them spending beyond their means.

And to whom are promises being kept?  Simple.  While this government is breaking its promises to producers and tax payers, i.e., the forgotten people who are always called upon to staunch the politician’s bleeding heart by paying for his vicarious generosity*, it considers it absolutely essential to keep promises to the parasites that their mis-named and unaffordable “entitlements” will be maintained.

It is the same delusion that is now dragging down every welfare state in the world.

The fundamental point that must be made again and again was said well by Henry Hazlitt:

_quoteThe mounting burden of taxation not only undermines individual incentives to increased work and earnings, but in a score of ways discourages capital accumulation and distorts, unbalances, and shrinks production. Total real wealth and income is made smaller than it would otherwise be. On net balance there is more poverty rather than less."

Shuffling around that mounting burden does nothing for prosperity.  What is necessary is removing it.

A responsible government would do that.

That they won’t do anything close tells you precisely how “ambitious” they really are.

Labels: ,

3 Comments:

Anonymous ACT Youth said...

David Farrar is part of that spin machine from the National party. Farrar can't tell the difference between bullshit and genuine National policies. Everything is just gold to him, so he just follow blindly without questioning the bullshits.

5/17/2010 10:09:00 am  
Anonymous LGM said...

Interesting what Eisman (manager of FrontPoint Financial Services hedge fund) says about those who worked in Wall St during the run up to the crisis and collapse.

"Not once have I come across a person inside a big Wall St firm who was having a crisis of conscience. Nobody ever said 'this is wrong'."

"What I learned from this experience was that Wall St didn't give a shit what it sold."

Basically he reckons they are ALL liars and con-men.

And THAT is the place where NZ sourced its PM. That place where bonds "backed" by mortgages three levels of dog shit lower than unqualified were rated AAA. That place where, when it was realised there were not ever going to be enough Americans with poor credit ratings taking loans to satisfy Wall St's demand for more to sell, they synthesised bonds out of nothing (bonds floating on a "derivative" abstraction of nothing). That place where "complicated financial stuff was being dreamed up for the sole purpose of lending money to people who could never repay it." But hey, it generated fees and lots of bonuses....

Now tell us, are any of you really surprised about broken tax-cut promises? How many of you believed them? Come on now. Fess up, suckers!

LGM

5/17/2010 06:20:00 pm  
Blogger gregster said...

"While this government is breaking its promises to producers and tax payers, the forgotten people who are always called upon to stanch the politician’s bleeding heart by paying for his vicarious generosity*, it considers it absolutely essential to keep promises to the parasites that their mis-named and unaffordable “entitlements” will be maintained."

WELL SAID Sir.

5/17/2010 06:25:00 pm  

Post a Comment

Respond with a polite and intelligent comment. (Both will be applauded.)

Say what you mean, and mean what you say. (Do others the courtesy of being honest.)

Please put a name to your comments. (If you're prepared to give voice, then back it up with a name.)

And don't troll. Please. (Contemplate doing something more productive with your time, and ours.)

<< Home