Wednesday, 1 July 2015

Architectural Mini-Tutorial: Radiant Heat

 

LetItSnow
“Let it snow!”
The Frank Lloyd Wright-designed
Bachman-Wilson House.

 

Lots of homes new and old now have a system installed in their floors called “radiant heating,” sometimes just called “underfloor heating,” a system of heating coils in your concrete floor that (if used and installed properly) keeps it warm in winter even when it’s a winter wonderland outside.

Why is it so damn good when used properly, why is it often so widely misunderstood? (And who really invented it?)

To answer all that, we need to start by talking heat transfer.

Heat transfer

As anyone who’s ever tried to heat a draughty house will know, heat likes to transfer itself from warmer to colder. And as anyone who’s ever studied physics might remember, there only three main ways by which heat can be transferred:

  1. by convection, i.e., by air
  2. by radiation , i.e., by electromagnetic waves
  3. by conduction, i.e., by touch

And as anyone who has ever sat in front of an open fire will know, even when hot air is going up a chimney, if you turn your face to the fire you will still feel the fire’s heat, even from some distance away.

That’s the power of radiant heat – the second of the three ways heat is transferred. You can feel this same form of heat transfer from the sun too – heat transferred across the vacuum of space simply by electromagnetic waves, making it warm enough some days to sunbathe even in winter, from a heat source millions of miles away.

How we lose heat
How we lose heat to the environment

 

So radiant heat is really ‘the heat of the sun.’

Heat, and us

Now, transfer this knowledge to our own bodies, swaddled up on a winter’s night. Leaving aside sweating, i.e., evaporation (which is a nice-to-have on a hot summer’s day, but a bad way to lose heat on a cold winter’s night!) there are three ways our body loses heat.

  1. by convection, to colder air
  2. by radiation, to colder distant surfaces
  3. by conduction, to colder surfaces we’re touching.

Now, it’s obviously nice to have a warm floor so we don’t lose heat by conduction through our feet. But as you can see above, losing heat through our body’ peripheral parts is not our biggest heating problem (depending of course on which peripheral parts we’re talking about!). Mostly, we need to avoid losing excessive heat from our body’s core. And it turns out that we lose just over a third of our body’s heat by convection, lost to cold air, yet we lose nearly two-thirds of our body heat by radiation to colder surfaces.

That’s important.

It means that heating people is not so much about keeping people warm, as stopping them cooling down – and, paradoxically, we arrive at the conclusion that the very best way to warm someone most directly is to warm the surfaces around them. (Yet, unfortunately, so many of the most common heat systems installed in our homes heat the latter, and ignore the former!)

Funny stuff, eh.

So, do that right, gently heat your surfaces to avoid major heat loss from our bodies, and we can create beautiful open spaces that feel perfectly comfortable to be inside in all weather, and we needn’t feel stuffy even in winter.

The greatest misunderstanding

Got that? You’re heating your surfaces to avoid losing heat from your body. You are not trying to heat the air. Yet this is the greatest misunderstanding that many people harbour about radiant heating: that you are trying to heat your floor in order to heat your air, so they turn up their underfloor heating until the air feels warm and the room suitable stuffy. That couldn’t be more wrong:  You are heating your floor to stop the people within losing their body heat to cold surfaces. Try using your floors to heat the air instead and you’ll still be as stuffy as buggery, and your power bills will start getting the extreme attention of your bank manager.

And your bank manager need not be concerned if your system is well installed (perhaps with a heat pump as heat source) and it’s intelligently used. Because, once you understand that all these systems need to do is to minimise the difference between the floor and our body temperature, you understand that these radiant heat systems don’t even need to be turned up high to do their main job.

Even a temperature of 18oC or so can be enough to make a room feel comfortable and, if we have heating pipes on our terraces, they can even melt all that snow. And because exposing skin to warmer surfaces exposes us more directly to radiation, we might even enjoy the experience better by sitting around in our shirtsleeves!

It also, incidentally, makes a more comfortable temperature gradient for the human body (above), without the head copping the majority of our heat!

Who really wants a hot head in their house?

Some history

So, where did this really neat ‘new’ idea of radiant heating come from? Turns out it’s not so new.

In modern times, the idea came from that genius Frank Lloyd Wright, who had it installed in his first Jacobs House (below) in 1936, in the cold American Midwest climate of Wisconsin. (The pic at right shows the necessary under-floor heating pipes laid out all ready for the concrete pour in the very similar 1939 Pope-Leighey House).

The owner-builder of the Jacobs House (Herbert Jacobs) liked the experiment so much he installed it again in his second Frank Lloyd Wright house – in a place with even larger glass windows in an even less hospitable clime -- and Wright installed it in virtually every house and commercial building thereafter.

It not only liberated the buildings from awkward and unsightly heating appliances, it allowed large open spaces –and even open windows! – even on cold nights in frigid climates.

The application was new, but the idea itself was ancient. Wright ran hot water in galvanised steel pipes in the first Jacobs House, but centuries before that the Romans had built fires to heat hollow ducts, or hypocausts, in walls and ceilings in homes, pools and their sacred buildings.

But Wright didn’t get the idea from them, at least not directly. He first encountered it in Japan where, in his patron Baron Okura’s otherwise frigid Japanese house, there was a basement space they called “the Korean Room” to which everyone retreated of an evening. Wright’s account well describes the feeling of a good radiant heat system.

This room was about eleven by fifteen feet, ceiling seven feet [says Wright]. … We knelt there for conversation and Turkish coffee.
    The climate seemed to have changed [from the frigid rooms above]. No, it wasn’t the coffee, it was Spring. We were soon warm and happy again—kneeling there on the floor, and indescribable warmth. No heating was visible, nor was it felt directly as such. It was really a matter not of heating at all but an affair of climate.

The Baron’s interpreter explained that Spring was created by heating the floor in precisely the same way as the Roman hypocaust system. Wright immediately felt that it was such a natural way to heat a home, and almost immediately tried to incorporated what he called “gravity heat” into his new buildings. He enthused:

image

image

There are now as many different systems to choose from as there are misunderstandings about what the system is trying to do (even, I might even say especially, by many installers). But when you’re installing, or thinking of installing, a radiant heat system today, take comfort that you’re part of a legacy that goes back to the Romans and to ancient Korean sages, through Frank Lloyd Wright – and that by heating your concrete floor, you’re using the most efficient way to most directly heat a person’s body in open space.

You're installing heat superior even to that of the sun!  Even when it snows outside.

 

** Thanks for reading. I hope you’ve found this mini-tutorial a useful
way to see an important element of modern architecture.**

 

[Pics from New-Learn Info, NBM, Prairie Mod, www.earlybritishkingdoms.com, www.litbrix.com]


Frank Lloyd Wright’s Brandes house, enjoying the snow

.

4 comments:

  1. I've always wondered how these underfloor systems work, because I knew they don't get particularly hot. Thanks for the explanation.

    ReplyDelete
  2. In-floor heating is great but it is not cheap to run (using conventional electricity anyway)

    ReplyDelete
  3. Can be, should be, if perimeter and sub-floor insulation sufficient, installation is a smart one, and (most importantly) temperatures are kept low and use is made of off-peak power. Biggest problem I've seen is caused by teh misunderstanding about how radiant heat heats; peaople are still trying to use the heated slab to (over) heat the air rather than just warming the slab to around 18 degrees to 'remove the chill' from the surfaces and minimise body-heat loss to those colder surfaces.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Just came across this interesting account of America's first affordable housing, in Levittown:
    "Levittown’s radiant system used serpentine copper pipes embedded in concrete slab floors to carry the water, which was pumped and heated via a squat boiler that sat in the kitchen right next to the other appliances. William Levitt’s Executive Vice President, Irwin “Jal” Jalonack, was responsible for this design. Jalonack started his career as a plumber, then became an HVAC engineer, and he was the one who made the decision to use oil-fired hot water radiant systems in Levittown. He searched long and hard to find those little boilers that would fit in the kitchens. They were made by York-Shipley Company, and the trade dubbed them the “low-Yorks” because they were just a bit taller than a washing machine. Most of those boilers continue to heat Levitt homes to this day, the ones that still use radiant heat. I guess you could say Jal was the man who brought radiant heat to the masses in America. Levittown’s goal as a development was to bring affordable, economic-to-maintain houses to the general public, and radiant floor heating helped it succeed."

    ReplyDelete

1. Commenters are welcome and invited.
2. All comments are moderated. Off-topic grandstanding, spam, and gibberish will be ignored. Tu quoque will be moderated.
3. Read the post before you comment. Challenge facts, but don't simply ignore them.
4. Use a name. If it's important enough to say, it's important enough to put a name to.
5. Above all: Act with honour. Say what you mean, and mean what you say.