Thursday, 11 April 2013

Peter Schiff on David Stockman

Peter Schiff talks about the impact and arguments of former Reagan Budget Director David Stockman, and his new book The Great Deformation: Corruption of Capitalism in America.  Because it was written by a former insider, it’s been making waves, Stockman’s critics “shooting the messenger” rather than dealing with his severe criticisms …

In reference to an op-ed piece by Stockman in the New York Times, for example, “Corruption of Capitalism in America,” Krugman dismissed the ex-congressman as a "cranky old man" without even reading the book.

Actually, I was disappointed in Stockman’s piece. I thought there would be some kind of real argument, some presentation, however tendentious, of evidence. Instead it’s just a series of gee-whiz, context- and model-free numbers embedded in a rant — and not even an interesting rant. It’s cranky old man stuff…

Naturally, Stockman fired back.

3 comments:

the druinken watchman said...

"Because it was written by a former insider, it’s been making waves, shooting the messenger rather than dealing with the arguments…"

you mean the critics of Stockman are shooting Stockman? or Stockman is shooting a messenger?

Peter Cresswell said...

Sorry, it was a little poorly written, wasn't it.

the drunken watchman said...

no ...i wasnt being pedantic, it was a serious question.

(call me slow on the uptake) but I presume the messenger being shot is Stockman?