Tuesday, 5 March 2013

China’s property bubble

It should have been history’s greatest example of a successful exit from years of totalitarian rule. Instead, it might prove to be history's greatest property bubble, ahead of what could well prove to be history’s largest property crash.

This 60 Minutes report on China’s Ghost Cities tells most of the story, and demonstrates what malinvestment looks like, but gives little of the cause and foreshadows only a little of the potential fallout when the bubble bursts.

The main cause the clip ignores is the Chinese government’s role in encouraging these projects and their money printing that has blown up this inflationary bubble—giving new buyers the idea that house prices will rise, will rise, will always rise and will keep rising. It’s like the pyramid scheme in Albania that boomed and burst after the collapse of socialism there, only on a much, much larger and more destructive scale.

As Robert Wenzel explains, Chinese politicians have a tiger by the tail:

At present, the Chinese economy is a combination of free markets and bizarre central planning. These ghost cities are heavily financed by local governments and the money that investors use to buy the properties is pumped about by China's central bank, The People's Bank of China. So much money has been pumped out by the People's Bank that price inflation is starting to cause civil unrest. The People's Bank of China and the government of China are trapped, the only way they can prop up the bubble is by more money printing, but that will cause price inflation to accelerate even more. If they stop printing, the real estate market and stock market will crash. It is possible it will result in the greatest crash in economic history...
When this thing crashes, one way or another, it will be blamed on China moving "too fast" in the direction of free markets. It will be a myth…

The fallout will be huge. America is partly financed by Chinese savings, which could well disappear in the bust. Australia has endured the depression only because it has been kept rich selling to China “the most commonly available commodities known to man,” there to be transformed into property no-one lives in. Demand for those commodities will plummet in the bust.

We do live in interesting times.


  1. And when Australia goes down New Zealand will fall further, harder. All you Kiwi fools make is milk. Actually, hold that, it's the cows that do that. You fellows are so indigent you don't actually make anything of merit in any quantity really. But, wait for it, "the country is so beautiful, it is the most beautifuly place in the whole wide world". Oh you stupid white trash. Lee Quon was right about you after all.


  2. You may be right, Amit, but you're still a very nasty fellow.

  3. I am damn right and you should not hurt the messenger. Fact is fact. A is A. And even when it hurts your emotions A is still A. Forget your soft weakness feelings and look at facts. You lot are non-productive and in debt. Guess what happen next when you can't pay back what you owe?

    Like Lee said, Kiwis are the poor white trash of the South Pacific. You all ridden with the debt just like a fly blown rotting carcass is ridden with the maggots. Yoou don't make enough of anything useful to other people---- well not enough to satisfy your high-cost profligate lifestyle of consumptive parasitism. Man, when the plug gets pulled out from under your $250-million dollasr per week debt fix, there will be your creditors who will move in and liquidate you, taking the collateral (collateral, you remember what is that don't you?.....the country is so beautiful, it is the most beautiful place in the whole wide world....THAT collateral nitwit!!!). Dunno what you'll do then? Maybe moan about unfairness and feelings & stuff or something.

    Get over yourself. Don't cry about it. You had the choice.

    Amit Cim PhD

  4. On the horizon I see trouble
    A double back to the last financial attack, a bursting bubble

    Standing in the rubble, the thunder makes us wonder
    What kind of disaster was this blunder?

    The whole world went under when the bubble went pop
    and now the fires 'ah burning and it's a blaze we can't stop


1. Commenters are welcome and invited.
2. All comments are moderated. Off-topic grandstanding, spam, and gibberish will be ignored. Tu quoque will be moderated.
3. Read the post before you comment. Challenge facts, but don't simply ignore them.
4. Use a name. If it's important enough to say, it's important enough to put a name to.
5. Above all: Act with honour. Say what you mean, and mean what you say.