Monday, 15 October 2007

Team Blue take Auckland. Ho hum.

John Banks and Team Blue now have a majority on Auckland's council, and Team Blue supporters are crowing that this and other Team Blue victories in local elections sends a message that should be heeded in next year's national elections.

I agree.

The message is, "Business as usual." I suggest to you that despite the anger over several years of rates rises and council meddling under a Hubbard mayoralty and a Red council, a John Banks mayoralty and a Blue council will do nothing to lessen either the rates bill or the meddling. Despite all the talk and all the crowing, by this time next year, both the meddling and the Auckland rates bill will be no less than they are now.

That's the real message these elections have for the national elections: that neither Team Red nor Team Blue represent any substantial alternative. In the words of the song, the message is, "Meet the new boss. Same as the old boss."

UPDATE: It's not so much that Banks won, but that Hubbard lost. Russell Brown points out that "John Banks has achieved his landslide win in the Auckland mayoralty election with almost exactly the same number of votes he attracted in his landslide loss three years ago: about 45,000... On a rough calculation, Banks won with about 40% of the vote, and the support of less than 15% of Auckland's registered voters." At the same time as Banks was receiving the same number of votes as last time, Dick Hubbard was receiving 27,000 fewer. Banks wasn't voted so much as the other bugger was voted out -- something that resonates with Aucklanders and with how mayoral candidates campaign:
  • Nine years ago, Christine Fletcher won with the single policy: I'm not Les Mills.
  • And six years ago, John Banks won with the single policy: I'm not Fluffhead Fletcher.
  • Dick Hubbard won three years ago with the single substantive policy: I'm not John Banks.
  • And now a "transmogrified" Banks wins again with the single substantive policy, I'm not Mother Hubbard.
We don't vote politicans in, we vote the buggers out. And what we find when we wake up again is that we've just voted another politician back in. "Meet the new boss. Same as the old boss."


  1. Its the lesser of two evils unfortunately.

    Still, we did get a decent whack of votes, blair and myself for instance getting about 2800 votes, out of 10,000ish that were returned in our area, on a new ticket, with a low budget for advertising, we did fairly well.

    Would be great to see people like yourself running next time.

  2. Who are you Mikee and where?
    Your results are impressive.
    I stood in Hamilton and got 583 for Mayor and 2027 for West council running as a Libertarian Independent.
    Tim Wikiriwhi

  3. You are probably correct Peter.

    I am just pleased that if rates and nonsense from the Council will be undertaken, at least the 'best' people ..(rich people who live in Remmers and the Eastern Bays).. will be doing it, rather than ghastly left wing cardigan wearers.

  4. Tim, I ran with Blair Mulholland (who did better than me) for council and community board in Eden/Albert.

    We ran on the ticket

  5. sure they wont be great shakes, they'll still be nanny-ish but rates wont sky rocket like they would with Mother Hubbard


1. Commenters are welcome and invited.
2. All comments are moderated. Off-topic grandstanding, spam, and gibberish will be ignored. Tu quoque will be moderated.
3. Read the post before you comment. Challenge facts, but don't simply ignore them.
4. Use a name. If it's important enough to say, it's important enough to put a name to.
5. Above all: Act with honour. Say what you mean, and mean what you say.