Showing posts sorted by date for query seriously unaffordable. Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query seriously unaffordable. Sort by relevance Show all posts

Wednesday, 4 January 2017

#TopTen | No. 5: But how do they *know* NZ is so prosperous? [updated]

 

Last year I wrote and posted 801 posts (“we are the 801”). And here at EnZed’s fourth-most read political blog this was the fifth most popular post: asking all those organisations regularly ranking NZ in their top tens, quite seriously, where exactly they get all their information from?


Have you ever wondered about all these international surveys always quoted so authoritatively?

I have one before me that finds NZ to be the most prosperous country in the world. Issued by something called the Legatum Institute – a think tank founded, we are told, by “a private investment firm headquartered in Dubai” – the survey has been widely reported over the last few days by everybody who would appreciation the headline that “Free markets, free people, and the world’s strongest society ensure that New Zealand takes the top spot in Legatum’s Prosperity Index.”

Great! Right? They say: 

New Zealand has ranked first in the Prosperity Index for six of the last ten years. Bar a small prosperity drop as a result of the 2008 global financial crisis and the immediate impact of the Canterbury Earthquakes, New Zealand’s prosperity has been on an upward trend, particularly since 2012. This rise has been driven by concerted efforts by policymakers, especially in economic and health policy. New Zealand’s Business Environment performance has seen it rise nine ranks to 2nd, and in Health it has risen eight ranks to 12th. Underlying strengths include Economic Quality, particularly free and open markets, where New Zealand ranks 1st, Governance (2nd), Personal Freedom (3rd), and Social Capital (1st).

So break out the bubbly – as many of the commentariat do quite indiscriminately whenever any of these sorts of surveys are released, just as they did when several other surveys were released declaring New Zealand and its cities to be among the world’s happiest, the most prosperous and the most free. All just as breathlessly reported. (Oh, but also the most unaffordable. So there’s that too.)

So, it would all be great news if it were all true, right?  But if you catch yourself wondering about the degree to which we and our markets are truly free or NZ really prosperous, and how these authors would really know any of this -- especially in the detail they claim, down to several significant figures – then you’re not alone.

Me too.

It’s not just this survey. It’s all of them. I pressed one fellow once whose regularly cited “freedom index” alleged New Zealand at the time to be the world’s freest -- earning us their “gold medal for freedom” with scores like 9.6 out of 10 for property rights only a few years after the Resource Management Act had taken most of them away.

After a whole riot of wriggling to try to avoid the questioning, he eventually conceded that much of their data is based on subjective surveys sent out to selected “leaders” in each country. And from that news it didn’t take much more to learn that most of those surveys were completed by local cheerleaders desperately keen to trumpet the virtues of their hometown. (Q: Is your place a hell of place to do business? A: Big tick! Hell, yes!! You’re darn tootin’!)

So, garbage in, and garbage out.

But what about the Legatum Institute’s lovely-looking Prosperity Index?  On what basis precisely do we earn a 68.95 for something called “Social Capital” and an apparently whopping 84.27 for “Governance,” yet only 75.52 for education and a confusing 74.09 for “Natural Environment,” I wondered?

Where specifically do these numbers to that many significant figures come from?

And just how much of this country’s and the 260 others’ natural and business environments they’ve surveyed have the authors actually walked through? Or know anything about?

LegatumAnyone wondering about any of these things will just be left to continue wondering, it seems. The report’s methodology section does have a nice diagram full of words like “selecting the variables,” “standardisation” and “variable weights,” all things you can do at your own desktop once you have your numbers and making things all sound very sciency, and there’s even a nice picture of some kind of machinery (there it is on the right) accompanying an assertion that it is all “methodologically sound.” But of information on where all the numbers being crunched actually come from, we are simply left to scratch our heads and wonder. There is not even a section in the diagram for “gather and assess quality of data.” Which, if you are simply getting your data from subjective surveys of at least 260 very different groups people, you’d think would really, really matter.

Yes, one may read this:

For each country, the latest data available … were gathered on the 104 independent variables.

But how?

And from whom?

One should note the careful use of the passive verb there. “Were gathered.” For the fact is we are never fully told by whom, or even how any particular data was gathered, what data sources were relied on or how reliable (or not) the numbers in the sources may be, nor yet how the numbers from right around the world from (presumably) several thousand different data sources are correlated to all appear on the same scale. It is true that you can download all their data (and all neatly tabulated with to up to seven significant figures!) yet you will never be able to determine, for instance, how that 74.08751 for NZ’s “Natural Environment” was made up, or what objective method was used to give NZ a 84.274 for “Governance.”

I know. I’ve tried.

In their “2016 Methodology Report” we are told in general terms that data for all their 104 variables “are drawn from a wide range of sources including intergovernmental organisations such as the United Nations, World Bank, International Monetary Fund, and World Health Organization; independent research and non-governmental organisations (NGOs) such as Freedom House, Amnesty International, and Transparency International; and databases compiled by academics.” Which is all very nice as far as it generally goes. And “for the subjective variables,we are told that two major global surveys are relied upon: the Gallup World Poll and the Executive Opinion Survey organised by the World Economic Forum.” (Page 12 to 14 of the report is it when it comes to the explanations you seek, and is literally all of any explanation you are going to find.)

Yet when one does drill down into a few of these sources, even those they themselves call “objective,” one encounters a similar feeling of falling through quicksand with no means of support: the sources there are the often of the same style as this one, with data gathered either subjectively, or not at all, or from surveys like this one relying upon each other for support (Legatum cites Fraser Institute who cite Freedom House who cite Legatum who cite … and on an on). It starts to look less like objective information and more like a circle jerk within which each organisation simply preferences different data or weights all the same data slightly differently. And about the “executive opinion surveys” that seem to be the source of much of this stuff we’ve written before at length: if there’s a better way of giving a good score than inviting local boosters to talk up their marketplaces as places to invest then we haven’t yet discovered it.

So garbage in.

Yet they string all these subjective numbers together to four significant figures, and then total them up to issue press releases and hand out awards, yet just how these rankings are really earned, and where and how the numbers are actually gathered and formed we are never fully and truly told.

We are however given “a detailed description of the imputation techniques” utilised to produce missing data, which the reader may delight in finding in their “2016 Methodology Report.”

So, garbage out.

Are we happy and prosperous down here at the bottom of the South Pacific? Are we the most prosperous place on the planet? The truth is you’ll never know by reading junk like this. You will learn more by simply opening the window and looking around.

UPDATE: See, for what it’s worth this is a whole lot more rigorous than any of these alleged indices:

New Zealand has been named the world's best country by readers of Britain's ‘Daily Telegraph.’
    The winners of the annual ‘
Telegraph’ Travel Awards were voted on by more than 75,000 readers, with New Zealand emerging as the clear winner for the fourth consecutive year.

At least with these awards there’s no pretence about the judgement not being subjective. And with a sample size of 75,000, albeit self-selecting, it’s undoubtedly larger than that used to compile any of these bogus indices.


Tomorrow, I post last year’s fourth-most popular post here at EnZed’s fourth-most read political blog asking … if Greenpeace has the truth on their side, why do they need to lie so much?

.

Thursday, 18 August 2016

When did homes start becoming unaffordable?

 

When did homes start becoming unaffordable? Good question.

From 1957 to the late-1980s the median New Zealand house price was between two-to-three times the median annual household income. Back then they were affordable.(A city’s housing affordability is generally defined as having the median house price less than or around three times the median income.)

By the late 1990s, the average house price had already risen to four times the average household income, and houses began becoming inexorably unaffordable.

It wasn’t until 2008 however that headlines began happening and home-buyers became seriously worried, as prices peaked at a seriously unaffordable six and a half times the median household income in 2008. … 

Houses11

They peaked in other places. But in Auckland they just kept on going up. In Auckland now, they’re rapidly approaching a severely unaffordable ten times the median household income.

Houses14

If you're paying for your house out of your average income, I think you'd agree that's a very rapid rise into the territory marked as "severely unaffordable."

Great if you’re a home-owner.

Murder if you're not.

So what happened in the 90s to begin that tick up into unafforability?

Well, the 1992 Building Act is one. Far from being deregulation, as some still risibly claim, it implemented a new multi-volume building code, a new building bureaucracy, and an ageing and failing superbureaucrat to oversee it all. He failed very soon, as it happens, but we are left with the rotting bureaucratic system he left us that adds months to a consent preparation and application, and many thousands to the building cost of every house. (And as costs became higher and profits lower, fewer spec builders bothered to even try building-to-sell the new houses they had previously.)

Another thing that happened in the 1990s was National’s Resource Management Act, introduced by Simon Upton and then administered without change by Nick Smith (yes, children, that Nick Smith now insisting he must change it), an Act that brought about the greatest attack on property rights since the war and, with it, the most severe restrictions on the supply and use of building land ever seen before in this once nearly-Freeland.

So those are two reasons for home-buyers to weep right there. (Three, if you include the thought of Nick Smith.)

And what happened in Auckland around 2011? If you answered “Rodney Hide’s super-fucking-bureaucracy began really kicking in,” I reckon you might just get the prize. The new super-bureaucrats have made the city more expensive, building more difficult, and planning a development infinitely more uncertain – especially with the six-year process of implementing their Unitary Plan, which has created tremendous regime uncertainty1 among property owners and investors.

Even with an earthquake that destroyed most of its inner city and eastern suburbs, Christhurch has done better – which makes Rodney Hide’s amalgamation a bigger bloody housing disaster than their earthquake.

Auckland2

And while the city has always been ring-fenced by the central planners, it is only perhaps in the last few years that the ring-fence has become a serious constraint – one that the new Unitary Plan is reported to retain!

The story remains that unaffordable cities are generally cities that are constrained from building, and constrained from expanding.

More tomorrow.

NOTES:

1. Regime uncertainty is a concept developed by Robert Higgs describing a pervasive lack of confidence among investors in their ability to foresee the extent to which future government actions will alter their private-property rights.
    Higgs uses this concept to explain the seriousness and prolonged duration of some economic crises, like the Great Depression or the current 'Great Recession.‘
    According to Higgs, regime uncertainty explains at least in part the sluggish pace of the current economic recovery.
    Regime uncertainty pertains to more than the government's laws, regulations, and administrative decisions. For one thing, as the saying goes, "personnel is policy." Two administrations may administer or enforce identical statutes and regulations quite differently. A business-hostile administration [such as Len Brown’s] will provoke more apprehension among investors than a business-friendlier administration [sorry, can’t think of one], even if the underlying "rules of the game" are identical on paper.

.

Tuesday, 9 August 2016

Sun sets on solar

 

sol2

Renewable energy is generally unaffordable energy. It’s unreliable energy. [It's not renewable, and it's barely energy.] For years, this so called “sustainable” energy has instead been heavily-subsidised energy – the alleged energy warmists would point to in arguing that conventional fossil-fuel energy should either be banned or taxed into extinction. Sustainable only by virtue of the subsidies, and utterly unsustainable without.

A whole alleged industry on the mooch.

But the sun is now setting internationally on solar power, and all those “green jobs” Russel Norman and his cronies talked about for years are revealed as nothing more than moonshine.

It’s been an interesting time of late. Within the last few weeks, Solar Trust of America (STA), owner of the world’s largest solar plant, filed for bankruptcy protection under Chapter 11, and nobody expects much of it, if anything, to emerge from it. STA joins a long list of companies in the solar energy sector, who’ve gone bankrupt, ducked into protection from their creditors, suspended production indefinitely or are simply circling the plughole.
    Across the world, a few of the more prominent and expensive casualties are Solyndra, Solar Millennium AG, Energy Conversion Devices Inc, Q-Cells, Solon, Solar Millenium, Solarhybrid, Ener1, Range Fuels, Beacon Power Corp and there’s a whole lot of others.

What else distinguished these companies other than the word ‘solar’ in their title?

Nearly all of these companies were the beneficiaries of huge government startup grants or loan guarantees.

Ah. They were all moochers. Cronies sucking off the state tit. A very green business model indeed.

The products they made were effectively sold to consumers with a subsidy, to make them more attractive. The customers also had the benefit of some generous feed-in tariff schemes. All that money that was sunk into them has now gone and the specific green industry sector it was expected to create, is pretty much moribund.

This is the very “green industry sector” Russel and the Greens have been touting. The cheerleading for mooching has continued under James Shaw – and would undoubtedly form part of any deal with whatever Government might partner up with them.

Yet even with the subsidies these green succubi were unsuccessful, consuming more resources than they ever produced. And the wreckage is not confined to the US.

In Germany, which gets the same amount of sunshine as the US state of Alaska and where inexplicably nearly half the solar power output of the world was installed, investment experts expect not a single solar cell company to be in business in five years time, since not one of them is currently showing an operating profit, nor is expected to do so in the foreseeable future. In Germany alone, the government have to date handed out about €100 billion in subsidies to renewable energy and even there, the most fervently green country in Europe, they’ve begun to have some serious doubts. It’s a money pit. The promised green jobs haven’t appeared and unemployment in the developed nations continues to rise. On a world-wide basis, the money wasted runs into the billions of dollars.
    Billions and billions and we’ve ended up with pretty much nothing. Actually, that’s not quite correct. What we will have, within a decade or two, is a clear up job that’ll make Chernobyl look like a training day. As the vast arrays of panels age, they’ll crack and contaminate the topsoil with poisonous chemical particles. Take a careful look at the picture below, because that’s what we’ll have to pay to detoxify, and make no mistake, we’ll be the ones paying, despite a few of the companies installing these panels having given undertakings to dispose of the panels at the end of their service life. The hard-nosed investor in me reckons they’ll be safely bankrupt by the time any such expensive undertakings have to be honoured.

solar-farm-poison

I wonder where we will store all that contaminated topsoil? Perhaps wherever we’d planned to store nuclear waste, before we decided not to build any more nuclear plants.

So why are all these crony companies going bust? Simple: they were never profitable from day one, and were never going to be profitable thereafter. Their whole business case was based on subsidies.

[But[ subsidies …were never supposed to last forever. They were part of larger stimulus packages, which were only supposed to get those businesses up and running. If the business proposals and revenue projections were correct, all those companies should have been running profitably by now. They patently weren’t, so pretty much the same questions arise ….
    The business case for the whole industry was supported by numerous studies by scientists, academia, so-called industry experts and advocates of renewable energy, all of whom said it was the clean and profitable future of energy production. Obviously, all those studies were seriously wrong and ended up costing governments billions. Has anyone got back to these “experts” and asked why the studies and their financial models were all so bad? Given how shoddy their expert advice has proven to be, is anyone asking for the money back, which we paid for this supposed expertise? In the light of how bad expert advice in this area has been, is anyone reviewing advice for similar green sectors, such as wind power? Anyone? Anywhere?

Of course not. And you can double-damn guarantee that you’ll be hearing the same bullshit business case being made by the Greens again from here to the next election, lapped up and regurtitated without research by their lamestream media colleagues. Yet,

Never in the history of the world, has such an amount of money been wasted, without any trace of financial oversight or accountability. Not only has the money been squandered, but at a time of high unemployment, the fashionable rush to create illusory green jobs, has actually destroyed jobs in the real economy. A study in Spain concluded that for every green job created by their massive renewables investment, the real economy lost 2.2 real jobs and only one in ten of those green jobs created, will be permanent. The much touted transfer of jobs from the real economy to the green economy simply never occurred either. Similar studies in Britain, Canada and Scotland have come back with equally appalling numbers.

Do we need to repeat that here?

In the UK, they’re calling the rise in this fashionable non-energy and the rocketing energy prices it creates “fuel poverty” – poorer folk pushed into extremity by the rinsing price of energy under David Cameron’s subsidies of the fashionable and carbon taxes on the reliable.

The UK’s Department of Energy and Climate Change’s (DECC) latest report in July 2011, which only gives figures up to 2009, estimated that 18% of UK households were then officially classified as being in fuel poverty. The UK Citizen’s Advice Bureau, again a guesstimate circa 2009, is concerned that 5.5 million people in UK face living in freezing conditions through Winter, because of self-rationing or disconnection. Given the steep jump in domestic power prices over the last three years, the figure must now be well over 25%.

Must we really repeat that here?

Governments wasting vast amounts of taxpayer’s money on financially absurd projects is always bad but if the net effect of doing so, is to impoverish and harm their own most vulnerable citizens, then it’s unforgivable.

It would be.

.

RELATED POSTS:

  • “Dr Norman says ‘‘smart, green economics’ is the way to go because the international market for sustainable products and clean energy technology is growing rapidly.’ Really? Is that right?
        “Well, no.  It’s not. Like virtually everything else the Ginger Whinger says, it’s not right. Not right at all. The international market for “clean energy” is bankrupt.  Not just struggling. Not just a little bit bankrupt. It’s completely, wholly and abjectly bankrupt.”
    Russel: 'Don’t sell the power companies—throw money my way instead'
  • “Russel Norman is still talking about “a smart, green economy” as if that were an actual thing. It’s not. So why does the media not challenge Russel Norman for continuing to pretend he owns the source to some economic magic bullet?”
    Smart green failure
  • “Russel however continues to talk about "a smart, green economy.” But the fact is, no such thing exists—at least not in the terms he means, with bans on power producers and subsidies for so-called “green tech.” The failure of any “green stimulus to get off the ground—in Spain, in Germany, in the US—even with huge motivation and billions of dollars in subsidies is just another clue that Russel is talking nonsense…
        “If Russel really does want some lessons from economics for his environmentalism [as he claims he does], he might reflect that the whole of economic activity consists in creating new values and, new goods and new resources, and moving them and transforming them to the place(s) and the state in which they are most valued… But this fact continues to elude Russel and his followers, who continue to cry wolf while remaining blind to the incredible results all around him.”
    Re-designing Russel’s “green” economics
  • “Renewable energy is economically unsustainable energy. Google thought they could change that. Google failed.”
    Renewable energy is still unsustainable energy

.

Tuesday, 2 August 2016

Yellow peril update

 

So, are New Zealand houses being snapped up in their droves and taken away to China, as so many of the commentariat have been chattering about?

No, say the figures.

For the second month running, figures show that the numbers of Chinese buyers in the market are … trivial. Just 1.5% of all buyers. Put another way” %98.5 of buyers are not Chinese, and 97% are New Zealanders (defn.: “those who are tax-resident in NZ”).

Sorry if that bursts so many bubbles (but not yet this housing bubble), but there it is. NZ’s houses are not seriously unaffordable because of the yellow peril, too many (or too few) investors, immigration, land bankers, carpet sprawl or because we’re becoming a rich country. They are seriously unaffordable because we have too many buyers with too much newly-created mortage-money borrowing chasing too few houses on too little land that cost far too much to build.

All those problems are political, or caused by politics, which is why all the politicians who helped cause it all want to point all those fingers elsewhere, but the facts are that the furphies they point to are just not any of the primary causes. They did it. They just don’t want you to know that.

My prediction therefore: this latest news will do nothing whatsoever to stop the continuing claims from all the ignorati that the Chicoms are over here stealing our houses. Or the peddling of sundry other myths by all the assorted myth-makers. Facts and figures never bother them, do they.

.

Tuesday, 12 July 2016

#HousingCrisis | Zoning for special interests [updated]

 

In not being able to pay its own way, Labour's cure for affordable houses is unaffordable -- and in planning to confiscate private property both National and Labour plans are immoral. Yet even in their intentions (and politicians actions are judged not on results, but only on intentions) then even then, neither party are actually proposing producing houses that are actually affordable.

Affordable houses are generally considered to be houses with an average selling price of only 3 times average income for that area (a house price-to-income ratio met by Auckland as recently as the early 1990s).* Labour’s stated aim is to produce houses of around $500,000 to $600,000 – and National’s plan lacks even that paltry ambition. Yet at that price, that would still make a house price-to-income ratio of around 5 or 6.

So Labour’s seriously unaffordable plan is to make houses that are severely unaffordable.

Unaffordable
Table from 12th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey: 2016

Nice.

And meanwhile, the current state of the law ensures that the housing crisis will continue.

It’s like neither party actually has any genuine solutions to the crisis their laws have caused. Yet the answers have been known for decades.

HCrisisI refer you again to a simple book that’s been on my shelf for well over thirty years. Its solutions are comprehensive – one simple solution being to outlaw zoning --

If … there were no zoning or land-use control laws, there would be considerably more housing at considerably lower prices and in areas considered more desirable.

Both common law and the systems set up in un-zoned cities like Houston protect freedom and property owners far better than zoning, which has only been imposed for a few decades. The problems are evident, the solutions are known, yet zoning of every New Zealand city continues.

Men are born free but nearly everywhere in zones. Why? Because (as my well-annotated copy told me so long ago) so many cronies benefit from it.

Housing4
          Housing3

These are just a few of the interest groups who benefit from zoning – to them these days we might add the councillors and politicians whose campaigns are part-funded by the beneficiaries, the bankers who get to lend in an over-priced market, the increasing sea of well-remunerated resource consultants (who will become even richer come the dawn of Auckland’s new Unitary Plan), the older owners of rapidly inflating inner-city property, and the circle of land-owners around the outer ring of NZ’s cities awaiting and lobbying for re-zoning; all of them  making hay out of other people’s misery.

Nice.

But it doesn’t need to continue …

NOTES:

* “The Median Multiple (this house price-to-income ratio) is widely used for evaluating urban markets, and has been recommended by the World Bank and the United Nations, and is used by the Joint Center for Housing Studies, Harvard University. Similar house price-to-income ratios (housing affordability multiples) are used to compare housing affordability between markets by the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, the International Monetary Fund, international credit rating services, media outlets (such as The Economist) and others.” [Source: 12th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey: 2016, p. 6]

RELATED POSTS:

  • “The winners in this equation are those who already own property in the inner suburbs, mostly older generations. Restrictive land-use regulations have severely constrained the supply of housing in most Australasian cities, pushing prices up.
        “It is, in effect, a massive wealth transfer from the young to the old.”
    'Regulations that limit the stock of housing suitable for younger people, such as height restrictions and view shafts, need to be axed and pronto' – Jason Krupp & Alex Voutratzis, INTEREST.CO.NZ
  • The Coming to the Nuisance Doctrine is the only objective means of determining who has the right to continue using his property in the event of a nuisance. If zoning is to be replaced, therefore, it must be replaced with the Coming to the Nuisance doctrine.”
    The "Coming to the Nuisance" doctrine: The antidote to zoning – CAPMAG
  • “’When the productive have to ask permission from the unproductive in order to produce,’ said Ayn Rand, ‘then you may know that your culture is doomed.’ That’s true. Just ask anyone who has waited in line for a resource consent.”
    What would 'Party X' do about [affordable housing]? - PART 3: Small Consents – NOT PC
  • “Here is how the housing market works under John Key’s crony capitalism: he and his housing minister and the council’s planners have between them just made around half-a-dozen land-owners around Auckland rich beyond their wildest dreams.
        “Announcing out of the blue some land allowed to selectively slip through the council’s zoning net, the land-owners quickly discovered their land formerly zoned rural by planners now had the politicians’ and planners’ tick to build houses – and the value of said land immediately went through the roof.”
    Windfall profits for some at the expense of affordable housing for others – NOT PC, 2014
  • “Is zoning and urban planning racist? Are environmentalists guilty of racial injustice? Are planners the new segregationists? Yes, says Randal O'Toole of the Thoreau Institute.”
    Zoning and 'Smart Growth': The New Segregation? – NOT PC, 2006
  • “Here's a lesson that town planning advocates everywhere should note.  While most of the American housing market has experienced boom and bust in the face of expansionary Federal Reserve policies, housing in Houston has remained relatively immune -- even though it's been at the epicentre of rapid economic growth due to the commodities boom.
        The reason?  While most of the western world is under the thumb of town planners, with the result that housing in much of the western world has become seriously unaffordable, the city of Houston remains unzoned, and its housing among the most affordable anywhere.”
    Why Houston housing has avoided boom and bust – NOT PC, 2008
  • “Kip's Law:  "Every advocate of central planning always — always — envisions himself as the central planner.”
    “Planning” to stop Aucklanders plan – NOT PC, 2011
  • “What do town planners mean when they talk about things like ‘affordable housing’ and ‘community’?
    What they don’t mean is making houses affordable, or about any ‘community’ other than their own.
    The weasel words of “planning” power-lust – NOT PC, 2010

Monday, 11 July 2016

Labour’s affordable housing plan is seriously unaffordable

 

There's a simple question that explodes Labour's just-made announcement to build 100,000 houses -- a staged build, they say, with the later stages built on the back of profits made the sale of early stages.

There's a simple question, and that question is this: If it were all that easy, then why isn’t everyone already doing it? 

It’s not like there isn’t plenty of money around to borrow: banks are lending money into existence for mortgages at an ever-increasing rate (two-thirds of all new money borrowed into existence, at an eight percent increase in quantity year on year; just one reason for this bubble.)

And land keeps getting “released” by council, making it available (in theory) for anyone to build on who can afford to buy it.

So what could a Labour Government do that a whole welter of speculative builders aren’t able to?  Because if there were profit in building and selling homes at $500,000, including land, then we and those speculative builders and land bankers would already all be doing it, wouldn’t we?

But we aren’t, because we can’t.  The affordable end of the market for speculative builders, the people who built this city and most major western cities, is dead. They can’t make a profit on a home at that price – not with the cost of land + building (see below) + external works and external services + borrowing costs + council costs + delays + …..

So the Labour Party promises $2 billion for this plan – $2 billion for 100,000 houses, plus theft. That’s just $20,000 for every house, or $200,000 for each one if they build just 10,000 in the first tranche to get the money to pay for the next.

But if there’s no profit in that first tranche, then there’s no next tranche, is there?

And if there’s no next tranche, then there’s no real plan, is there.

And there is no plan that’s worth a damn, is there, because if there were any profit in building affordable houses, then everybody would be out there doing it.

And they’re not doing it because with their ever-increasing gold-plated rules and regulations and Resource Management Act, successive governments have made building affordable homes just too damned expensive – and not one of the damned parties who’s done all of that what’s to do anything at all to arrest that, i.e., to fix the market to make the model for affordable spec profitable again.

Instead we just get more bullshit announcements like this one – an unaffordable way to attempt to make housing affordable.

NB: Think it’s cheap to build a house? Andrew Little does. The big home-builders know otherwise. Here below the average cost in 2015 for a home from NZ’s top ten group-home builders, not including the price of land + external works and external services + borrowing costs + council costs + delays + drapes and coverings and on and on and on. And if you think you can get hold of reasonable land inside Auckland for anything less than $250,000 … you’re dreaming. Let alone on the scale he’s dreaming about. So do Andrew’s sums for him, and see how much profit they would have to pay for their second tranche…

HouseBuilders-2015

RELATED POSTS:

  • “Do you see the problem already? Even excluding the rocketing price of land – about which Labour pledges to do precisely nothing -- the Labour Party’s maths requires thousands for homes to be built for well under $300,000, or  as Labour’s housing spokesman Phil Twyford concedes, the Labour Party's Kiwibuild policy ‘will quickly run out of money.’
        “Yet the very room full of actual experts in which Twyford made that concession – at a conference on affordable housing filled with people talking honestly rather than talking their book -- had already established that homes by the thousand, or even by the dozen, could not be built for well under $300,000 or anything like that, leaving the Labour Party's Kiwibuild policy as little more than a wet rag to wave around on the election trail that will quickly run out of money if they ever get a chance to try it.”
    Labour’s Kiwibuild policy "will quickly run out of money" – NOT PC, 2014
  • HCrisis“Housing crises? They’ve been with us for decades – and the answers to them are no secret. It’s not that the solutions that are in short supply, it’s the political will.
        “I have in front of me a book that’s been on my shelf for more than thirty years…
        “Every answer to this present housing crisis in there, and has been known for decades. You can see just from the chapter headings that that because the causes of virtually every housing crisis are political, the solutions to every housing crisis are the same…”
    A housing crisis, four decades on – NOT PC
  • “So a theft of property rights now to ‘fix’ a crisis almost wholly caused by their previous and ongoing theft of property rights! What could be more ingenious!!
    Nick Smith’s government land-grab - NOT PC
  • “The key to making Auckland liveable is to make it affordable—a fairly complicated and heavily politicised subject, so let’s try to make it simple: we won’t have an affordable Auckland until the model for ‘spec’ building  is viable once again.
        “Spec building being ‘speculative’ building—a builder buying land, building a house and ‘speculating’ he can sell it to a buyer for a reasonable profit. This is how the vast majority of NZ’s cities have been built, by small builders hoping to make a modest profit.
        “But in recent years this model has broken… The problem is that even while housing prices have rocketed, both land and building costs have skyrocketed.”
    Fix spec building to make Auckland affordable again – NOT PC, 2013

Wednesday, 18 May 2016

Little lulled into Otara overcrowding oversell

 

Back in Bill English’s 22% election campaign in 2002, his leadership campaign team organised a standup in a bus intended to be crawling though peak-hour Auckland traffic to highlight to the accompanying media the problems of Auckland traffic that the National Party would fix in record time. Instead, it was the one morning that Auckland traffic worked, and the only thing that went in record time was the bus, sailing into the city with neither let nor hindrance from the traffic.

Mr 22% just couldn’t catch a break.

Neither can Labour’s Mr 25%.

Lulled by the stories from the media and his local MP, Andrew Little booked a standup with media outside a house he’d never visited, in a suburb he didn’t know, to tell the media a story he’d taken on trust.

This was the house selected by his team to tell the story of overcrowding in South Auckland housing. This was an example calculated to to elicit tears. They’d been told they were all of them, media, flunkies and fools, standing around handwringing outside a house filled with 17 people. Turned out that was nonsense. The house was not overcrowded at all.

A man came out to say he was the owner of the house and the claims had been greatly exaggerated… “They say there’s 17 people living here, it’s not true,” he said.

The media circus moved on, with Little still in the frame as ringmaster. Samiuela and Lupe Tukutau, the minister and his wife at the local Free Wesleyan Church of Tonga in New Zealand, spoke alongside the Labour leader as, unable to find the overcrowding they sought in the wild, they headed back to see if they couldn’t find it in the local Labour office.

A lack of suitable housing was a huge issue in the South Auckland area, the Labour leader said [when they arrived back from the show]. "I'm told it's pretty much expected if you go past a garage someone will be living in it.”

A more diligent media would have begun peering into those garages.

A more questioning media might have asked the minister’s wife how much she and the minister take each week in tithes from their impoverished parishioners.

More insightful senior members of the media may even have undertaken some real investigation of the homeless numbers and overcrowding stories taken by everyone, like Little, on faith,

None of this happened. (Perhaps the overcrowded office took the ginger out of them?) Instead, they simply printed Labour leader Little’s conclusion:

"This is not the New Zealand that New Zealanders want."

It’s certainly not the media we want,or would pay good money for.

Nor, I suspect, is this the sort of performance Labour supporters would want: making a circus out of something they claim to know is a serious issue.

Housing in this city is no joke. It is seriously unaffordable -- as measured by objective indices.

Remedies to that seem utterly beyond the political classes who have caused it, and in some cases can’t even find it.

Thursday, 17 March 2016

Mayoral candidate says housing should grow ‘out’

 

Great to see an Auckland mayoral candidate recognising that if house-price inflation be tackled, then the city has to be ready to grow out.

Auckland mayoral candidate John Palino is calling for the removal of the urban-rural boundary to improve housing affordability.
    The boundary, known as the metropolitan urban limit, was restricting land supply in Auckland and driving up house prices for ideological reasons, Mr Palino said today.

And he’s right, you know, it does, and is:

  • Land just inside this “urban fence” costs around ten times land just outside. For virtually identical land. Nothing else so demonstrably highlights the effect of regulation, nor gives some idea of what might be achieved by relieving it.
  • And the reason for the “urban fence” is completely ideological – both “new urbanists” and te apostles of “sustainability” preach higher densities for their own separate reasons, but mostly for reasons of control.

My own position is that to promote affordability the city needs to grow both out and up – which recognises home-buyers have the right to choose, and land-owners have the right to build.

‘Out and Up’ should be the mantra.

But at least one mayoral candidate is loudly saying ‘out.’

[Hat tip Stephen Berry from Affordable Auckland, the only mayoral candidate saying ‘Out and Up.’]

RELATED POSTS:

  • “So Auckland can’t grow out, because Auckland’s ‘planners’ and public-transport advocates say so.
        “And it can’t grow up, because councillors voted last night that they say so: Auckland Council voting 13-8 to pull new 'denser' maps from the Unitary Plan process.
        “So what are would-be home-owners to do who are trying to afford their own home in a seriously unaffordable city?
        “And what are property-owners to do who wish to build and sell to those desperate to get on the property ladder?”
    Up or out? From both sides council says NEITHER! – NOT PC
  • “It is not primarily the fault of land developers that the American suburbs are thought to be dysfunctional and mundane. The blame belongs largely to the influence of boiler-plate zoning regulations combined with design consultants who seek the most minimum criteria allowed by city regulations.
        “Yet for all its problems, decade after decade 80% of new home purchases are not urban, but suburban. Some (architects, planners, and university professors) suggest we should emulate the dense growth of other nations not blessed with the vast area of raw land within our country, yet most of those countries as they prosper strive to emulate our American suburbs.
        “The planning of our cities is about design. Yet, for the past quarter century a highly organized group consisting mostly of architects (acting as planners) have pushed a New Urbanist agenda that is as much about social engineering as it is design.”
    Designing suburbs: Beyond 'New Urbanism' – Rick Harrison, NEW GEOGRAPHY
  • “Auckland Mayor Len Brown’s fear of Auckland sprawling “like Los Angeles” is unfounded, pictures of the city’s growth over the past 30 years suggest.
        “A timelapse image of Auckland produced by Google shows New Zealand’s biggest city barely grew out at all between 1984 and 2012 (see pictures), despite its population increasing from 850,000 to more than 1.3 million during that time.
        “This is in stark contrast to many cities elsewhere, including the US where the likes of Houston, Dallas-Fort Worth and Atlanta have expanded rapidly.
        And critics say this footage undermines mayor Brown’s claim that Auckland is a sprawling city that needs to be contained.”
    Google busts Len Brown’s Auckland ‘sprawl’ claims – Niko Kloeten, NBR [via Whale Oil], 2013
  • “What’s missing here is choice.  In talking about about development on either “greenfield” or “brownfield” sites, both advocates insist that folk do things their way. They completely ignore the fact that people have the right to choose where and how they live, particularly if they own the place on which they choose to settle down.
        “Let people live where they wish to, as long as they bear the costs. And let those choices themselves—choices based on people’s own values for which they are prepared to pay the cost—organically reflect the way the city develops.
        “Ironically, it’s the very promoters of intensification, the planners themselves, who have done the most to make decent intensification more difficult.  Here's just some examples of a few urban housing types that are enormously popular overseas, but could barely be even contemplated here…...”
    “Sprawl” versus “intensification” – NOT PC, 2012
  • “Sprawl is good. Sprawl is choice. The opponents of sprawl are not just against sprawl, they're against choice -- the proof of this is that if people wanted to live in the way the enemies of choice wanted, they wouldn't need to be forced into it, they'd be doing it anyway.
        “The enemies of sprawl are the enemies of choice -- they simply use the power of government and the powers that the Resource Management Act gives local government to force people to live in the way that they prefer, rather than the way the people themselves wish to live. They're just another brand of interfering busybody who want to force their own predilections upon others.
        “The result in New Zealand is severe restrictions on building and development, and the result of that is some of the most unaffordable housing in the world.”
    Envy is making houses unaffordable – NOT PC, 2007
  • “But my point here is that not everyone wants to live that way, and forcing people who would rather live otherwise into the planners' favourite cookie-cutter solutions removes any possibility of their planning their own future the way that they would like to; it removes their ability to make their own decisions based upon long-term considerations; and it's causing something no-one could really celebrate. And that's really the whole point, isn't it?
        “When it comes to housing, let's all be Pro-Choice.”
    More sprawling arguments – NOT PC, 2007
  • “Most of the planners in New Zealand's major cities have imposed what's called a Metropolitan Urban Limit around the cities. This is sometimes called an 'urban fence,' inside which development proceeds (in theory) according to the planners' whims …
        “Outside the urban fence, development only proceeds to the extent that land-owners outside the fence can dodge the planners' desire to make a rural museum of the area surrounding the cities, and to the extent that developers who have built up land banks around the city can encourage their chums on council to relax the zoning, or to release the urban fence just a little. You might call this a sort of 'informal' public-private partnership…
        “The sameness and the sprawl that many people object to in our present-day suburbia are in large part due to these regulatory measures that the anti-sprawlists themselves favour. Specifically, the "carpet sprawl" that would have few explicit defenders is created by the very 'Smart Growth' policies considered so progressive by so many planners. Owen McShane explained the process … ”
    Message to planners: "Don't fence me in!"- NOT PC, 2007

.

Thursday, 25 February 2016

Up or out? From both sides council says NEITHER!

So Auckland can’t grow out, because Auckland’s ‘planners’ and public-transport advocates says so.

And it can’t grow up, because councillors voted last night that they say so: Auckland Council voting 13-8 to pull new 'denser' maps from the Unitary Plan process.

So what are would-be home-owners to do who are trying to afford their own home in a seriously unaffordable city?

And what are property-owners to do who wish to build and sell to those desperate to get on the property ladder?

The collective answer to both that is coming from across all floors of the mega-council is this: “Fuck you.”

* * *

If last night’s vote to ban building up was a victory for anything, it was a victory for NIMBYism—for Not-In-My-Backyarders who successfully clubbed together to lobby councillors to stop their neighbours intensifying.

Make no mistake, last night’s vote to throw out the intensification proposed by the proposed Auckland Unitary is certainly not a victory for property rights. This proposed plan represents one of the very few times that council’s planners have actually and actively looked to allow property owners to increase the density on their land. Last night’s vote represented the antediluvian reaction to that: from those neighbours fearful of what effect that intensification might have on them.

It is true that everything someone does on their property may have an effect on their neighbour. It is also true that the proposed Unitary Plan does little to reflect the valid fears that neighbours of intensification might have.

But it is not beyond the wit of man to develop gudelines for minimising the effect of three-storey housing on a neighbour (three-storey housing being virtually all the intensifiation proposed). Indeed, it was not beyond the aegis of common law in ages past to recognise that if intensification is to proceeed while respecting property rights, then rights to light, to air, to support and so on must be protected.

I see little reason why those same protections cannnot be formally recognised today.

Instead, we have the worst of both worlds.

We have a city in which folk can’t build either out or up, in which would-be home-owners continue being locked out of their city – and in which the unsustainable bubble continues to bulge tumescently.

It is not a matter of young folk needing to buckle down and do what their older generations once did--buy a small house on the outskirts and save, save, save. It is a fact that house prices have risen well beyond what is actually affordable, and even able to be saved for, precisely because of the very rules those older generations have put in place.

* * * *

median-multiple-rbnz_0

The house-price-to-income multiple is a simplified, yet internationally recognised measure of housing affordability … defined as the ratio between median house price and median annual household income, otherwise known as the median multiple.
    T
he World Bank also says this ratio is "possibly the most important summary measure of housing market performance, indicating not only the degree to which housing is affordable by the population, but also the presence of market distortions."
    Based on this official work, it seems to have become accepted that a median multiple of 3.0 times or less is a very good marker for housing affordability. [Interest.Co.NZ]

Historically, New Zealand’s house prices hovered well below a median price-to-income ratio of 3.0,making houses for most of New Zealand’s history very affordable. This was the era in which previous generations bought their homes.

Capture

Since the mid-nineties however (curiously, at almost the precise time as National’s Resource Management was introduced), that ratio changed radically – and is now all-but out of control.

M-M-2016
Source: Demographia: 12th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey: 2016

There are many reasons for the rocketing rise in Auckland’s housing unaffordability, from the way new money is loaned into existence in the form of new mortages (in a process invented and maintained by monetary ‘planners’), to the way Auckland land has been kept off the market (in a process over which town ‘planners’ maintain a stranglehold over Auckland property-owners’ land). I don’t intend to relitigate them here (burrow into the archives if you can bear to). I simply wish to talk about choice.

Would-be home-owners have no choice.

They are being priced out of their city.**

And now it is clear home-owners have no choice either. They can’t build either out nor up.

This is not a recipe for a liveable city. It is certainly not a recognition of property rights.

I don’t say that we should be “pro-sprawl.” I don’t say that we should be “pro-intensification. I say, and I’ve been saying it for time, WE SHOULD ALL BE PRO-CHOICE!

The latter group characterise the former as being in favour of “sprawl”; the former characterise the latter as promoting the construction of the slums of tomorrow.

Both are right, and both are wrong.

What’s missing here is choice.  In talking about about development on either “greenfield” or “brownfield” sites, both advocates insist that folk do things their way. They completely ignore the fact that people have the right to choosewhere and how they live, particularly if they own the place on which they choose to settle down.

Let people live where they wish to, as long as they bear the costs. And let those choices themselves—choices based on people’s own values for which they are prepared to pay the cost—organically reflect the way the city develops. …

We let them ring-fence the city and stop people heading out and building away from the city when they want to —“sprawl!” is the all-too hysterical cry — and then we let them stop other people building higher density urban housing when they want to. Instead of leaving people free to choose, we have these boring “halfway houses” that some people like, but that many simply accept because that’s all that’s available, and they don’t know any better.

When there’s just so much available, so many great housing types  from which to choose, it just doesn’t make any sense.

“Sprawl” or “intensification”? That’s a false dichotomy. I say let people be free to choose.

That’s the path to genuinely liveable cities, and to affordability.

If only anyone truly gave a shit.


* And let those folk who think National’s Nick Smith is serious about improving housing affordability reflect that as Environment Minister in the mid-nineties the very same Nick Smith administered the Resource Management Act for many years, and did precisely nothing at all to change it.

** Let the NIMBYs reflect at least that many of these folk are their own children and grandchildren, who they may be driving out of the place they grew up.)

RELATED POSTS:

  • “'Smart Growth' fan Tom Beard challenged my encomia to sprawl the other day. As I summarised at the end of last week, my argument was essentially that in lifestyles and the places where we live, we should be Pro-Choice…”
    The sprawling argument continues. – NOT PC, 2007
  • “Last week I put out a post on possible mechanisms to enable groups of neighbours to protect their interests in their own and each others’ properties, while allowing the flexibility for them, rather than councils, to determine what, if any, and when changes in the land use rules affecting that group of properties would be put in place.”
    An interesting approach to urban land use property rights – CROAKING CASSANDRA, 2015
  • “Libertarian blogger Peter Cresswell, author of the Not PC blog, says Auckland sprawl is a myth peddled by planners and politicians.
        “’The only uncontrolled sprawl is in their heads.  Auckland’s ‘sprawl’ has been contained, constrained, ring-fenced and ringbarked—and the dreams of would-be first-home buyers with it.
        “’What Aucklanders need is not to be told by planners where and how they live—either in high densities or in quarter-acre sprawl or in small hamlets or country houses miles from the city centre.
        “’What they need in their housing is choice – the ability to choose where and how they live based on their own values, their own desires, and the often limited ability of their bank accounts. What they don’t need is to be told by planners, who are just out of school, that their choices are illegal.’”
    Google busts Len Brown’s Auckland ‘sprawl’ claims – NBR [via Whale Oil], 2013
  • “Those against increasing the urban limit are not just saying they don’t want to live further out – but they want to effectively ban others from doing the same.  They don’t want people to have choice – they want everyone in an inner city apartment.”
    Housing affordability – KIWIBLOG, 2012
  • “Ironically, it’s the very promoters of intensification, the planners themselves, who have done the most to make decent intensification more difficult.  Here's just some examples of a few urban housing types that are enormously popular overseas, but could barely be even contemplated here…...”
    “Sprawl” versus “intensification” – NOT PC, 2012
  • “There will be no innovations in NZ’s high-cost labour-intensive building techniques until innovative systems such as this can be painlessly introduced and exploited—perhaps only when councils themselves are taken out of the chain of responsibility for policing building standards…”
    Government finally plans to address unaffordable housing. But… – NOT PC, 2012

Wednesday, 26 March 2014

Strange Bedfellows: Christchurch Mayor Lianne Dalziel & the Rockefeller Foundation

Guest post by Hugh Pavletich

Former Mayor Bob Parker Goes … A Great Start …
Former Mayor Bob Parker threw in the towel mid-2013 (knighted thereafter for his services to public relations and for bending the knee to central government), and in the subsequent election nine of the 13 members of the Christchurch City Council were either replaced or withdrew themselves. Since then however new Mayor Lianne Dalziel has struggled in the job.

The Peoples Protest .. Clear Direction Forward …
The clean-out of the Council had its foundations in the 4,000+ strong Peoples Protest on 1 February 2012, with its demands clearly set out within their Christchurch Protest Committee letter to Nick Smith . These was later amplified with the op-ed ‘Christchurch: The Way Forward.’

In essence they  were at the time …

  • a fresh mid-term election
  • a replacement for the Chief Executive
  • restructure council from a centralised top-down agency to a “One City – Many Communities” model
  • affordable land for housing and business
  • affordable rates

It was clear to the citizens of Christchurch, if not to the new Mayor, that the “top down” layered bureaucratic approach to the recovery has been a total failure.  It was also clear that if a sound recovery was ever to get underway then a focused approach restoring control back to the people and their communities would be essential.

International Research Clear … Top Down Doesn’t Work …
There was already abundant international evidence that the “bottom-up” approach is the only way to go. For a recent illustration, see: Beito and Smith: Tornado Recovery—How Joplin Is Beating Tuscaloosa.

Strangely, the biggest disaster has not been the earthquakes themselves but the political and bureaucratic response. It still is. A series of earthquake events that should have cost around $15 billion will now be seeing costs upward of $40 billion, with delays commensurate with that magnitude (refer ‘Christchurch earthquakes: Council stalled recovery’).

With the capitulation of former Mayor Bob Parker last year, the resignation of then Chief Executive Tony Marratt and the unravelling of the team around them, a political vacuum was created into which Dalziel has been drawn.

Monday, 20 January 2014

NZ housing now more unaffordable than everywhere but Hong Kong [updated]

image

Every year since 2005, the Demographia organisation has been measuring housing affordability across the cities of the English-speaking world. As the planning virus continues with no abatement, the results have been increasingly horrific – especially for New Zealand house-buyers.

This year, with even more cities included, is no exception, with New Zealand’s major urban markets more unaffordable as a whole than any place measured outside Hong Kong.

Do you hear me, planners? More unaffordable than any place outside Hong Kong …

clip_image002

MEDIA RELEASE
Monday 20 January 2014

10th ANNUAL DEMOGRAPHIA INTERNATIONAL HOUSING AFFORDABILITY SURVEY

Super City ... with price tag that matches – New Zealand Herald INTERACTIVE MAP

The 2014 10th Annual Edition …

The 2014 10th Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey covers the expanded 360 urban markets of Australia, Canada,  Hong Kong,  Ireland, Japan, New Zealand, Singapore, United Kingdom and the United States.

The Annual Demographia International Housing Affordability Survey rates housing affordability , based on the Median Multiple – that is, the median house price divided by the gross annual median  household income of specific urban markets, for the 3rd Quarter of the previous year.

The “median multiple” is a robust measure – essential for the basic understanding of the structural health (or otherwise) of a specific urban markets.

If housing exceeds 3.0 times annual household incomes (requiring mortgage loads of about 2.5 times), it illustrates that there are serious political impediments that need to be addressed, with respect to land supply and infrastructure planning, provisioning and financing.

The fringes of an urban market are the only effective and sufficiently responsive supply and inflation “vents.”

Normal healthy urban markets, where housing is at or below 3.0 times annual household incomes are rated “affordable”; 4.0 times and below “moderately unaffordable”; 5.0 times and below “seriously unaffordable” and above 5.0 “severely unaffordable.

The results for all 360 urban markets covered within this year’s Survey are as follows …

image

The results of the 85 major urban markets (with populations in excess of 1,000,000) of the geographics covered  are as follows …

image

The Survey Schedules provide detailed specific gross annual household incomes, median house prices – and from that the Median Multiples.

Alain Bertaud, researcher and former Principal Planner – World Bank contributes the introduction …

The Introduction to this year’s Survey is Alain Bertaud, Research Scholar, Stern School of Business, New York University and former Principal Urban Planner – World Bank. Mr Bertaud has vast grounded experience internationally within the urban planning field.

Alain Bertaud makes it clear within this year’s Survey, why urban planning needs to change, asking …

“Are planners in the worst performing cities paying any attention?”

“And are they drawing any conclusions on how to improve the situation?”

Or do local governments conclude that the best way to increase the supply of affordable housing is to impose new regulations that will mandate developers to build housing units at prices, standards, and in locations selected by the government?”

“The last approach, under the name of inclusionary zoning is unfortunately the most common response, as recently seen, for instance, in New York and Mexico City.”

“Urban planners have been inventing all sorts of abstractly worded objectives to justify their plans for our future cities – smart growth, liveability, sustainability, are among the most recent fads.”

“There is nothing wrong, of course, for a city to try to be smart, liveable, or sustainable.”

“But for some reasons these vague and benign sounding objectives usually become a proxy for imposing planning regulations that severely limit the supply of buildable land and the number of housing units built, resulting in ever higher housing prices.”

“In the name of smart growth or sustainability, planners decide that densities should be lower in some places and higher in others.”

“Population densities are not a design parameter whose value depends on the whim of planners but are consumption indicators which are set by markets.”

“Even the Communist Party of China recently recognised that resource allocation is best achieved through markets; why can’t urban planners in so-called market economies reach the same conclusions and let markets decide how much land and floor space households and firms will consume in different locations?”

“It is time for planners to abandon abstract objectives and to focus their efforts on two measurable outcomes that have always mattered since the growth of large cities during the 19th century’s industrial revolution: workers’ spatial mobility and housing affordability.”

“As a city develops, nothing is more important than maintaining mobility and housing affordability.”

“Mobility takes two forms: first, the ability to travel in less than an hour from one part of a city to another; and second, the ability to trade dwellings easily with low transactions costs.”

“Housing mobility allows households to move to the location that best maximize their welfare.”

“Affordability is the ability for any urban household to be able to rent a dwelling for less than a 25% of its monthly income, or to buy one for less than about three time its yearly income.”

“The mobility and affordability objectives are tightly related.”

“A residential location that only allows access to only a small segment of the job market in less than an hour commuting time has not much value to households, even if it is theoretically affordable.”

image


UPDATE 1:  “Among all 360 markets in the principal analysis, there were 95 affordable markets,” none of which were in New Zealand …

image

image

The key correlation … ?

image